Please post sat pics of abottabad raid or live ops here except that "fake/propaganda pic of OBL's body (abduls lingo)". Where is dead body of OBL? I need DNA evidence from corpse.
Here is the basic question, what will you prove by "DNA evidence"? That Osama bin Laden is dead? Well, his own organization says he is dead. US claims he is dead and they killed him. His people (Al-Quaeda and his family) say he is dead and died in Abottobad. There is no conflict of claims so all evidence are now redundant.
Compare this to India's strike where there is a conflict of claim. India says it hit the training schools and killed terrorists. Pakistan says India did not and just blew up some trees and crows. All the publically available satellite evidence supports Pakistan's claim. See, the difference?
You search for evidence when there is a conflict of claim. If all things point to same way, it is quite likely that truth lies that way as well.
Balakot was in wikileaks as a terrorist training camp since long. You are not only raising questions on IAF but also on efficacy of onborad computers, Military sats and seeker of spice 2000 as you can only fire weapon when computer gives go ahead.
So we and others can inject sats at right orbit and elevation while same sats gives us wrong coordinates and images?
A precision bombing that too in mountains is a complex task involving many systems. An error can creep in somewhere because of many reason. To investigate and fix it is the task of military and its engineering corps. What lead to missing the targets (assuming targets were missed indeed) requires investigation. If it was sats, user error, guidance algorithm going haywire or incorrect topographic data those should be investigated.
If it is none of the above and they indeed hit the targets then military and government should be ready with their evidence. This was the second time they conducted the strike which was denied by Pakistan.
Really? How far was OBL from a major cantonment area of PA?
And if Pakistan is so "doodh ka dhula", why is Dr Afridi still in jail?
I am merely telling you what their claims are. What is "controversy" and what is indefensible. Ossam being killed in Pakistan and killed there is undeniable. They don't even attempt that. They had prior knowledge, that is something which is hard to prove so thats the position they are taking.
We could have driven them into a similar hard position by blowing up that madarsa sky high so they could have never claimed that we missed our targets. We did not. Thats my friend is a failure.
Agree to this. People who are crying IAF missed the target are basically saying that SPICE 2000 is a defective system.
A system can fail or user can make a mistake or its dependent systems can fail or simply the system can encounter a situation it has never enountered before. There are many things that can happen. No system is 100% fool proof and war tools have failed in the past too.
The job of military is not to give proofs.
That is an arbitrary qualification. Anyone who claims something has a burden to give evidence. If indian military and government claimed that they hit a target and their claim gets challenged then they better have evidence to the contrary. Especially when their claims in the past have been called into question. If they don't then their claims will carry less weightage in the future.
People who cry foul because some Wikipedia article thinks those bombings were fake they are either on chrislamocomie payroll or are infected with dhimmi virus.
The basic test of truth is this. The more you dig into it, the more evidence comes in its favour. The more and different sources we look for confirming the bombing : Planetlab images, Digital Globe images, the more evidence we find that the place was not hit. Remember, these are direct observations.
