Lok Sabha passes Citizenship Bill amidst Opposition outcry

Citizenship Act protests: 'I wait in silence as my world falls apart'

Rikat Hashmi, a Muslim student in Delhi, explains why she feels anxious about her future as an Indian Muslim.
Like many Muslims in India, I now spend my days wondering what the future holds for us.

Will I be denied a job because of my religion? Will I be evicted from my home? Will I be lynched by a mob? Will this fear ever end?
"Be patient," my mother tells me after a night of violence at my university campus - Jamia Millia Islamia - in the capital Delhi.
Students were allegedly beaten up, tear-gassed in the library and bathrooms, and terrorised to stop their protest against a controversial new citizenship law.

This law - the Citizenship Amendment Act - paves the way to citizenship for persecuted people from three countries, Bangladesh, Pakistan and Afghanistan. But it offers amnesty only to non-Muslim illegal immigrants.
Muslims have been excluded, and it's this discrimination that is at the heart of the students' protests.
But why did the police launch an assault on them?
They say it was because students torched vehicles and provoked a response, but where is the evidence against us?
Police say there was no firing, but what of those who lie wounded in hospitals?



I am studying for a degree in dentistry at Jamia university, and I've witnessed several peaceful protests during my time here.
I wasn't part of the protest on Sunday, which later turned violent. But I was a victim of the aftermath as police launched a widespread attacks on students.

I remember howling in fear as the police approached our hostel. We switched off the lights and tried to hide. The night passed and luckily, we were saved. But here's what is became clear: it didn't matter if you had voiced your criticism or not, because we were the target. We, the Muslims of India.

I remember waking up to the sounds of various Hindu devotional songs as a child.
We were the only Muslim family in a predominantly Hindu neighbourhood in the eastern state of Orissa.
We always celebrated festivals together - they would apply henna on my hands during Eid, and my siblings and I went to their houses to celebrate the triumph of good over evil during the festival of Navaratri.

Some of my Hindu friends would often come over to enjoy biryani, a popular dish of rice, meat and spices that is traditionally served in Muslim households.
There was no mosque in the vicinity, but my father wasn't too bothered by this since he wasn't a practising Muslim. My mother continued offering namaz (prayers) five times a day at our home.
I attended a convent school with a very large number of Hindus, and there was never a moment of religious difference.
Only once did a friend ask me about the myth that Muslims don't shower everyday, and I laughed it off. "We - I - definitely take a shower every day," I said.

Religion was a part of our lives, but I was never made aware of my identity as a Muslim. Until now.
Forces are out to divide us and I'm not sure if I can relive such experiences again.
We are increasingly being cast as meat-eaters, as rapists corrupting society, as terrorists defending Pakistan, as lovers converting Hindus, and as minorities who will take over the country.
In reality, we are on our way to becoming second-class citizens who must learn to live in fear.

In one of his tweets, Prime Minister Narendra Modi appealed for calm during the protests against the citizenship law. He said: "This is the time to maintain peace, unity and brotherhood."
A day before, in front of thousands of people and dozens of cameras, he had said: "People who are setting fire [to property] can be seen on TV... They can be identified by the clothes they are wearing."

He didn't elaborate but this seemingly veiled attack on my religion has, ironically, only made me more religious.
I don't mean this in the physical sense. I was 16 when I started wearing the hijab.
I had moved to the northern state of Uttar Pradesh to study Aligarh Muslim University, and I came across many young women wearing the headscarf.

It was an inspiring moment for me, and I decided to make it a part of my personality.
Today, at 22, I feel compelled to stand up and fight against the misinformation that is brazenly spread against my religion and my country's constitution. I want to voice criticism against discriminatory policies and the faltering economy.
But each time, I am rejected as "anti-national" or "anti-Hindu" and forced back into the shadows. I am told that I am "raking up the Hindu-Muslim issue" if I express my opinion against the government's policies.

We are living in a dangerous new era where religion and nationalism are intertwined.
Sometimes, I find people staring at me because of my hijab as I walk down the street
It may be an irrational fear, but the atmosphere of Islamophobia is certainly spreading. I want to call this out, but it's happening within full view of the media and the government.

The ruling party blatantly espouses a Hindu nationalist ideology and some laws are now based on religious discrimination. Vigilante groups are being empowered to carry out hate crimes against Muslims.
In these extremely unfortunate circumstances, voices of dissent are slowly fading out.
This isn't the inclusive India I grew up in, and we deserve better.
We, the 200 million Muslims of India.

The anxiety is building. We talk in whispers about how things could get worse with another law in the making that would require the entire country to prove their citizenship.
The home minister has promised the nation it will be rolled out before the next election in 2024.

But there's still hope.
Voices of support from across the country are rising above hatred and vile bigotry. Maybe it will inspire those who stand against us to re-emerge with reason and humanity?
For now, I wait in silence as my world falls apart.
I have been evacuated from the hostel and forced to go on vacation. My education has taken a hit. I can't travel to see my family as they live in another city where protests are boiling over.
So I park myself at the home of a local guardian, and recall my mother's words: "Be patient and hold on with all your strength."

As told to Pooja Chhabria, by Rikat Hashmi.
 
Rahul Kaushik (@kaushkrahul) Tweeted:
Mohd. Minhajuddin pelted stones on school buses, burnt public property & created mayhem in Jamia Nagar & adjacent areas on 14 Dec 2019. He was arrested by police.

Now, Kejriwal govt controlled Waqf Board has offered him a GOVT JOB & Rs 5 LAKH REWARD.

Just Wow! Rahul Kaushik on Twitter ( )


Aravind Limbavali (@ArvindLBJP) Tweeted:
This posture displayed during protest against #CitizenshipAmmendmentAct at Govt Arts College in Bengaluru clearly shows it is not really a protest against #CAA but a war against Hindus

This clearly has exposed their narrative. These are not protesters they are religious fanatics Aravind Limbavali on Twitter ( )
 
Citizenship Act protests: 'I wait in silence as my world falls apart'

Rikat Hashmi, a Muslim student in Delhi, explains why she feels anxious about her future as an Indian Muslim.
Like many Muslims in India, I now spend my days wondering what the future holds for us.

Will I be denied a job because of my religion? Will I be evicted from my home? Will I be lynched by a mob? Will this fear ever end?
"Be patient," my mother tells me after a night of violence at my university campus - Jamia Millia Islamia - in the capital Delhi.
Students were allegedly beaten up, tear-gassed in the library and bathrooms, and terrorised to stop their protest against a controversial new citizenship law.

This law - the Citizenship Amendment Act - paves the way to citizenship for persecuted people from three countries, Bangladesh, Pakistan and Afghanistan. But it offers amnesty only to non-Muslim illegal immigrants.
Muslims have been excluded, and it's this discrimination that is at the heart of the students' protests.
But why did the police launch an assault on them?
They say it was because students torched vehicles and provoked a response, but where is the evidence against us?
Police say there was no firing, but what of those who lie wounded in hospitals?



I am studying for a degree in dentistry at Jamia university, and I've witnessed several peaceful protests during my time here.
I wasn't part of the protest on Sunday, which later turned violent. But I was a victim of the aftermath as police launched a widespread attacks on students.

I remember howling in fear as the police approached our hostel. We switched off the lights and tried to hide. The night passed and luckily, we were saved. But here's what is became clear: it didn't matter if you had voiced your criticism or not, because we were the target. We, the Muslims of India.

I remember waking up to the sounds of various Hindu devotional songs as a child.
We were the only Muslim family in a predominantly Hindu neighbourhood in the eastern state of Orissa.
We always celebrated festivals together - they would apply henna on my hands during Eid, and my siblings and I went to their houses to celebrate the triumph of good over evil during the festival of Navaratri.

Some of my Hindu friends would often come over to enjoy biryani, a popular dish of rice, meat and spices that is traditionally served in Muslim households.
There was no mosque in the vicinity, but my father wasn't too bothered by this since he wasn't a practising Muslim. My mother continued offering namaz (prayers) five times a day at our home.
I attended a convent school with a very large number of Hindus, and there was never a moment of religious difference.
Only once did a friend ask me about the myth that Muslims don't shower everyday, and I laughed it off. "We - I - definitely take a shower every day," I said.

Religion was a part of our lives, but I was never made aware of my identity as a Muslim. Until now.
Forces are out to divide us and I'm not sure if I can relive such experiences again.
We are increasingly being cast as meat-eaters, as rapists corrupting society, as terrorists defending Pakistan, as lovers converting Hindus, and as minorities who will take over the country.
In reality, we are on our way to becoming second-class citizens who must learn to live in fear.

In one of his tweets, Prime Minister Narendra Modi appealed for calm during the protests against the citizenship law. He said: "This is the time to maintain peace, unity and brotherhood."
A day before, in front of thousands of people and dozens of cameras, he had said: "People who are setting fire [to property] can be seen on TV... They can be identified by the clothes they are wearing."

He didn't elaborate but this seemingly veiled attack on my religion has, ironically, only made me more religious.
I don't mean this in the physical sense. I was 16 when I started wearing the hijab.
I had moved to the northern state of Uttar Pradesh to study Aligarh Muslim University, and I came across many young women wearing the headscarf.

It was an inspiring moment for me, and I decided to make it a part of my personality.
Today, at 22, I feel compelled to stand up and fight against the misinformation that is brazenly spread against my religion and my country's constitution. I want to voice criticism against discriminatory policies and the faltering economy.
But each time, I am rejected as "anti-national" or "anti-Hindu" and forced back into the shadows. I am told that I am "raking up the Hindu-Muslim issue" if I express my opinion against the government's policies.

We are living in a dangerous new era where religion and nationalism are intertwined.
Sometimes, I find people staring at me because of my hijab as I walk down the street
It may be an irrational fear, but the atmosphere of Islamophobia is certainly spreading. I want to call this out, but it's happening within full view of the media and the government.

The ruling party blatantly espouses a Hindu nationalist ideology and some laws are now based on religious discrimination. Vigilante groups are being empowered to carry out hate crimes against Muslims.
In these extremely unfortunate circumstances, voices of dissent are slowly fading out.
This isn't the inclusive India I grew up in, and we deserve better.
We, the 200 million Muslims of India.

The anxiety is building. We talk in whispers about how things could get worse with another law in the making that would require the entire country to prove their citizenship.
The home minister has promised the nation it will be rolled out before the next election in 2024.

But there's still hope.
Voices of support from across the country are rising above hatred and vile bigotry. Maybe it will inspire those who stand against us to re-emerge with reason and humanity?
For now, I wait in silence as my world falls apart.
I have been evacuated from the hostel and forced to go on vacation. My education has taken a hit. I can't travel to see my family as they live in another city where protests are boiling over.
So I park myself at the home of a local guardian, and recall my mother's words: "Be patient and hold on with all your strength."

As told to Pooja Chhabria, by Rikat Hashmi.
As usual victim playing and fear mongering
 
Yes but that would not have helped BJP, esp with its core supporters.....
Exactly .. many white nations discriminate against non-whites in the implementation of a bill or law. But, here the messaging was more important than the number of people who might benefit from CAA.. The intention of excluding muslim refugees, could have been accomplished during implementation... but where is the fun in that...:p
 
  • Like
Reactions: S. A. T. A
Swati Goel Sharma (@swati_gs) Tweeted:
A faculty at IIT Kanpur has submitted this video and a complaint to director, alleging anti-India & communal statements made at a recent event held in 'solidarity with Jamia' & that event held without permission.

"When All Idols Will Be Removed...
Only Allah’s Name Will Remain" Swati Goel Sharma on Twitter ( )


Swati Goel Sharma (@swati_gs) Tweeted:
Dr Vashi Sharma’s complaint, that is also signed by 15 students, says there is an “immediate security situation” for him as well as those students who objected to the statements by crowd that day

Sharma told me the director has assured him of legal action
‘When All Idols Will Be Removed...Only Allah’s Name Will Remain’: Jamia Solidarity Event At IIT Kanpur Sparks Row ( )
 
Exactly .. many white nations discriminate against non-whites in the implementation of a bilthatl or law. But, here the messaging was more important than the number of people who might benefit from CAA.. The intention of excluding muslim refugees, could have been accomplished during implementation... but where is the fun in that...:p

What i cant understand is there nothing in the 5000 odd years history of the Hindu civilization that we can talk and take pride in, without having to hypenate with non-Hindus or spew hatred against non Hindus. This whole Hindutva politics of RSS is rooted in deep sense of cultural inferiorty and not in the 5000 years of cultural achievements of the Hindu( incuding the ealry Buddhist and Jain) civilization.....
 
  • Like
Reactions: vsdoc
@S. A. T. A since I have been thread banned, I'm replying bro your latest post here ....

There are guys on another forum on which @Deathstar thrives on who are openly gloating and boasting about the same.

About how they use their corporate position of power as recruiters to weed out Muslim candidates on some false pretext so as to disenfranchise them further.

This is not fiction. It's happening.

Cheers, Doc
 
@S. A. T. A since I have been thread banned, I'm replying bro your latest post here ....

There are guys on another forum on which @Deathstar thrives on who are openly gloating and boasting about the same.

About how they use their corporate position of power as recruiters to weed out Muslim candidates on some false pretext so as to disenfranchise them further.

This is not fiction. It's happening.

Cheers, Doc
Dude troll of the highest order lol
 
Dude troll of the highest order lol

Can you deny that what I'm saying is dishonest or false.

Hindus (a certain rabid kind) are using their positions of influence to keep promising and eligible educated Muslim youth from jobs they deserve.

It's called profiling. And it's being practiced across modi's India.

Cheers, Doc
 
@S. A. T. A since I have been thread banned, I'm replying bro your latest post here ....

There are guys on another forum on which @Deathstar thrives on who are openly gloating and boasting about the same.

About how they use their corporate position of power as recruiters to weed out Muslim candidates on some false pretext so as to disenfranchise them further.

This is not fiction. It's happening.

Cheers, Doc

I only hope this is not true.......
 
I only hope this is not true.......

I can tell you it's very true.

I know people in the real world who have boasted to me about the same, assuming since I'm a Parsi I am on with the game.

Wink wink.

Nudge nudge.

You know how it goes ...

Cheers, Doc
 
It's not at all offensive man.

You're a bong. In the US? But most places here it's just a form of speech.

You're not actually telling the other guy that he copulates with his sister.

Why get so autocratic?

Cheers, Doc

I am surprised about the feedback on moderation here, of all the forums I have been part of the moderating team here is quite chilled out.

Decorum is quite simple.

Internet forums like these are based on the ability to engage with each other respectfully. In any professional setting, I am pretty sure you are able to get your point through with using such language, you should have no problems here either.

Reading a post on a screen substracts the tonality from the conversation which is quite easy to misconstrue., So as a moderating position, No Curse Words directed towards anyone. You are free to hold a conversation in a language other than English if you want to be more colloquial, the admin is pretty chill here.
 
  • Like
Reactions: R!cK and vsdoc
I can tell you it's very true.

I know people in the real world who have boasted to me about the same, assuming since I'm a Parsi I am on with the game.

Wink wink.

Nudge nudge.

You know how it goes ...

Cheers, Doc

India and indians cannot perennially be at war with their fellow citizens and still hope to compete with emerging great powers in East Asia. We already wasted 30 years in this identity conflict and cannot lose anymore...
 
India and indians cannot perennially be at war with their fellow citizens and still hope to compete with emerging great powers in East Asia. We already wasted 30 years in this identity conflict and cannot lose anymore...

But we are.

And a lot of the opportunistic bhakts who are well off are now realising that and are beginning to tilt.

The shrillness of the BjP and it's reactions to the protests, on the back of the massive reversal in Maharashtra, is testament to the fact that they're massively spooked now.

They see their juggernaut grinding to a halt. And they will engineer blood to reverse that.

Count on it.

Cheers, Doc
 
But we are.

And a lot of the opportunistic bhakts who are well off are now realising that and are beginning to tilt.

The shrillness of the BjP and it's reactions to the protests, on the back of the massive reversal in Maharashtra, is testament to the fact that they're massively spooked now.

They see their juggernaut grinding to a halt. And they will engineer blood to reverse that.

Count on it.

Cheers, Doc

Congress played with a such a divisive agenda when its fortune was on the downswing during the 80's and we paid a heavy price for such shortsightedness...
 
Congress played with a such a divisive agenda when its fortune was on the downswing during the 80's and we paid a heavy price for such shortsightedness...

I am more scared of the BJP.

To put it crudely, India can manage a few million radical Muslims.

India will not survive millions of radical Hindus.

It's time for real Hindus to clean house.

Cheers, Doc
 
I am more scared of the BJP.

To put it crudely, India can manage a few million radical Muslims.

India will not survive millions of radical Hindus.

It's time for real Hindus to clean house.

Cheers, Doc
what percentage of hindu population are few million and what percentage a few million are of muslim population? ypou want hindus to clean up thr house but you have not voiced similar treatment for muslims? this shows your true colours my dear nakli parsi.
 
But we are.

And a lot of the opportunistic bhakts who are well off are now realising that and are beginning to tilt.

The shrillness of the BjP and it's reactions to the protests, on the back of the massive reversal in Maharashtra, is testament to the fact that they're massively spooked now.

They see their juggernaut grinding to a halt. And they will engineer blood to reverse that.

Count on it.

Cheers, Doc


The massive reversal? BJP might not be in power but still got most seats in Maharashtra. Now as far as the reversal is concerned, The massive incompetence of SS, along with legendary administrative skills of NCP/Congress; I will be quite surprised to see if this Congress-Sena combine will last 12 months.

As far as shrillness of protests, this "bong in US" has seen quite a few in Maharashtra, when Police have beaten public in ways that would make Jamia look like a picnic. The attitude of Law Enforcement hasn't changed, only thing that has changed is 24hrs News Network, Messaging Apps and Camera Phones.
 
  • Agree
Reactions: _Anonymous_
what percentage of hindu population are few million and what percentage a few million are of muslim population? ypou want hindus to clean up thr house but you have not voiced similar treatment for muslims? this shows your true colours my dear nakli parsi.

Look boss, your seniority works on kids here. Not on me. We are likely the same vintage.

I'm infamous on PDF and WAB as vsdoc.

Sanghi vsdoc. Over a decade.

Apex sanghi. You Hindus are pale second copies when it comes to me and Islam.

I don't need your ratification or to explain myself.

My posts are all there on the internet.

As are the guys who've known that vsdoc.

Cheers, Doc
 
Look boss, your seniority works on kids here. Not on me. We are likely the same vintage.

I'm infamous on PDF and WAB as vsdoc.

Sanghi vsdoc. Over a decade.

Apex sanghi. You Hindus are pale second copies when it comes to me and Islam.

I don't need your ratification or to explain myself.

My posts are all there on the internet.

As are the guys who've known that vsdoc.

Cheers, Doc
You have still not answered me. Why dont you preach same treatment to muslims which you preach to hindus?