Operation Sindoor: India Strikes Terroist Camps Inside Pakitsan

Sathya said:
Click to expand...
If Pakistanis used Shaheen, 2 questions to be answered
1) why BMD didn't intercept it? Its the job of BMD not s400.
2) Why retaliatory nuke strike didn't initiated? If Shaheen had launched,its our duty to rain Pakistan with nuke missiles before Pak BM reaches its target in india. A big & Unforgivable inaction from ourside.
 
Defc0n said:
The incident of Pak using Shaheen-2 seems to me like they wanted things to spiral - imagine that missile striking Delhi!

I am also concerned about our military reaction doctrine for BMs, depending on your AD/BMD is okay, but in case it failed to intercept the missile, then what? As per our nuclear doctrine which as been discussed multiple times, the very news of BM in air should have triggered a counter response, imagine the worst case, those egg-heads did indeed fire a nuke towards Delhi, and we were not prepared to strike back!
I guess only saving grace was the count of the BMs fired (would they fire just 1, mostly not) although this remains to be seen and confirmed by official sources.

I am deeply worried about us agreeing to the CF on 10th with this news coming out now - should have taught Pak lesson of their life time with BMs raining down all over Pak. This showed them that Pak can get away with this kind of stuff - they will do it again!
Click to expand...
As per OSINT and decent analysts sitting in various capitals - Kirana hills was indeed targeted. Only thing left was an all out war. That response seems okay. Agreed?
 
  • Like
Reactions: Rajput Lion
Shan said:
As per OSINT and decent analysts sitting in various capitals - Kirana hills was indeed targeted. Only thing left was an all out war. That response seems okay. Agreed?
Click to expand...

No, disagree on that. The protocol for a BM strike (Enemy BM in air) is a counter strike with BMs - whatever happened in Kirana hills can be seen as a warning (it worked because -
a. Their BM didn’t have a nuke (most likely)
b. We intercepted it successfully.

However, deterrence is based on the fact that any BM strike will be responded to with a massive counter strike, that’s the protocol- what does our action show about our protocol/will/readiness?

Giving benefit of doubt for a BM launch, sorry, that should never have happened!
 
  • Like
Reactions: Rajput Lion
Defc0n said:
The incident of Pak using Shaheen-2 seems to me like they wanted things to spiral - imagine that missile striking Delhi!

I am also concerned about our military reaction doctrine for BMs, depending on your AD/BMD is okay, but in case it failed to intercept the missile, then what? As per our nuclear doctrine which as been discussed multiple times, the very news of BM in air should have triggered a counter response, imagine the worst case, those egg-heads did indeed fire a nuke towards Delhi, and we were not prepared to strike back!
I guess only saving grace was the count of the BMs fired (would they fire just 1, mostly not) although this remains to be seen and confirmed by official sources.

I am deeply worried about us agreeing to the CF on 10th with this news coming out now - should have taught Pak lesson of their life time with BMs raining down all over Pak. This showed them that Pak can get away with this kind of stuff - they will do it again!
Click to expand...
We need the s500,David's Sling and iron dome apart from Kusha and akash ng.
Also the MRSAM needs to be upgraded to its final version integrating the Barak MX and Barak LRAD,SRAD to it. The Pakistanis will make sure to find a way to penetrate our AD.
Also the Krashuska needs to be procured from the Russkis.
 
  • Haha
  • Like
Reactions: ArgonPrime and Rajput Lion
Hydra said:
If Pakistanis used Shaheen, 2 questions to be answered
1) why BMD didn't intercept it? Its the job of BMD not s400.
2) Why retaliatory nuke strike didn't initiated? If Shaheen had launched,its our duty to rain Pakistan with nuke missiles before Pak BM reaches its target in india. A big & Unforgivable inaction from ourside.
Click to expand...
Field Marshal Sawhney, please post this on tweeter. You might get traction there.
 
  • Haha
  • Agree
  • Like
Reactions: ArgonPrime, Patriot001, Asterion Moloc and 3 others
Pakistan has the solid backing of the Chinese and the turks behind them. There should be no more ambiguity and dilly-dally behaviour from the Indian foreign ministry regarding this issue. Combating them rationally and with a cool head in the media sphere as well as in the international arena will do wonders. Smarter tactics in the PR/IR fields are needed. Lacking on this front to be honest.
 
  • Like
Reactions: RationalGuy, Rajput Lion and Hydra
Tatvamasi said:
Field Marshal Sawhney, please post this on tweeter. You might get traction there.
Click to expand...
OMKV
Shan said:
Pakistan has the solid backing of the Chinese and the turks behind them. There should be no more ambiguity and dilly-dally behaviour from the Indian foreign ministry regarding this issue. Combating them rationally and with a cool head in the media sphere as well as in the international arena will do wonders. Smarter tactics in the PR/IR fields are needed. Lacking on this front to be honest.
Click to expand...
What we received recently is a blue moon opertunity, i don't think that pak will give another chance.
 
  • Haha
Reactions: Rajput Lion
Hydra said:
Click to expand...
get this printed in intl. newspapers/defence weeklies etc. and have it gain traction. a win waiting in wings. people who have contacts within can give this suggestion.
 
  • Like
Reactions: ArgonPrime, Ironhide, screambowl and 2 others
You must log in or register to reply here.
Top Bottom