India-US Relations

It is self serving, totally duplicitous & reeks of arrogance. Imagine India doing the same for selling weapons to pakistan or having trade ties with china. If they do such thing we should simply recall our ambassador and downgrade to consul relations. Its not the end of the world, either way we need to face china , US or no US.

They are treating an enemy state the way it's supposed to be treated though. If our own industry was capable enough, CAATSA wouldn't have mattered to us. And of course they will present it as though they are doing India a major favour. All their strongarming tactics have failed. They know that India will choose Russia. The CRS report further presses home that fact. So this dog and pony show is a face-saving measure.

Furthermore, CAATSA exists because they fear Russian competition in the Middle East and ASEAN defence markets. Russian weapons have become ridiculously cheap. Not a single western country (any country as a matter of fact) can compete with the Russians on price point. So the only way to beat them is to kick them out of the game.
 

Joint Statement on India-US Counter Terrorism Joint Working Group and Designations Dialogue​

The eighteenth meeting of the India-US Joint Working Group on Counter Terrorism and the fourth session of the India-US Designations Dialogue was held in Washington, D.C., on October 26-27, 2021. Mahaveer Singhvi, Joint Secretary for Counter Terrorism at the Indian Ministry of External Affairs and John T. Godfrey, U.S. State Department Acting Coordinator for Counterterrorism, led their respective interagency delegations. Reaffirming counter terrorism cooperation as an important pillar under the India-US Comprehensive Global Strategic Partnership, both sides pledged to further expand cooperation on law enforcement, information sharing, exchanging best practices, and increasing strategic convergence on counter terrorism challenges.

The United States reiterated its commitment to standing together with the people and government of India in the fight against terrorism. Both sides strongly condemned any use of terrorist proxies and cross-border terrorism in all its forms and called for the perpetrators of the 26/11 Mumbai attack to be brought to justice. They also called for concerted action against all terrorist groups, including groups proscribed by the United Nations Security Council (UNSC) 1267 Sanctions Committee, such as al-Qa’ida, ISIS/Daesh, Lashkar-e-Tayyiba (LeT), and Jaish-e-Mohammad (JeM).

In line with UNSC Resolution 2593 (2021), both sides called on the Taliban to ensure Afghan territory is never again used to threaten or attack any country, shelter or train terrorists, or plan or finance terrorist attacks. Both sides committed to continuing close consultations on developments in Afghanistan and potential terrorist threats emanating from there. The two sides also exchanged views on countering narco-terror networks and trans-national illegal weapons smuggling networks.

Consistent with UNSC Resolution 2396 (2017), the delegations discussed ways to prevent the ability of international terrorists to travel. They also jointly decided to further expand terrorist threat information sharing, and exchanged information about priorities and procedures for designating terrorist groups and individuals.

The participants shared best practices on countering terrorism financing and use of the internet for terrorist purposes and decided to continue counter terrorism cooperation in multilateral fora. Both sides emphasized the importance of upholding international standards on anti-money laundering and combating financing of terrorism by all countries. They also discussed mutual legal and extradition assistance and opportunities for bilateral law enforcement training, including at the Central Academy for Police Training in Hyderabad, India. Both sides applauded ongoing Anti-Terrorism Assistance (ATA) training.

The dialogue affirmed the growing strategic partnership between the two countries in the shared fight against global terrorism.

New Delhi
October 28, 2021
 

Pressing Def+Ctrl+Alt in the 2+2​

The India-US 2+2 dialogue of foreign and defence ministers in Washington, as of now set for December 8, is a good opportunity for a comprehensive stocktaking and to discuss strategies, especially on Afghanistan and Pakistan. Differences must not be allowed to become sore points. With two Quad leaders’ summits, a bilateral meeting between Joe Biden and Narendra Modi, the first visit by chief of defence staff Bipin Rawat, and other exchanges under their belts, officials have to focus and deliver on the expanding agenda.

The third round was held in the very last days of the Donald Trump administration. The idea was to firm up as many promises and projects as possible to make it easier for the new regime to build on, and, at the same time, make it harder to dismantle. Currently, differences on Afghanistan where India and the US don’t see eye to eye pose difficulties. India was not consulted on the Doha deal and remains in the dark about the ‘secret’ annexures. But some US observers feel that India should have vehemently objected to Zalmay Khalilzad’s operation to highlight his deeply flawed approach and create pressure to improve or scuttle the deal.



With feuds among Taliban factions continuing, the question of ‘recognition’ is crucial. So far, the US has no plans to release the $7 billion in Afghanistan’s assets it holds. But how long till Pakistan ups the ante? Pakistan remains a critical US partner, and a formal agreement on use of its airspace is reportedly in the works. Rest assured it will come at a price for India to do ‘something’ — to help Pakistan behave better.

However, there’s good news on the India-US defence front. A new chapter is set to open on India as a ‘major defence partner’, officials tell me. The two sides are ready to sign a new ‘Space Situational Awareness (SSA) agreement’ between the US Space Command and Indian Space Research Organisation (Isro). The agreement, to be signed during the 2+2 dialogue, will allow exchange of information on space debris, space weather and the many madly orbiting satellites.

It sounds esoteric. But SSA is crucial, as outer space begins to have ‘traffic’ problems with a boom in commercial satellites. The idea is to avoid collisions, accidental or otherwise. Effects of the two worst space events in history — China’s 2007 anti-satellite test and the 2009 head-on between two communication satellites, a derelict Soviet Kosmos 2251 and a US Iridium 33 — are still felt today. The two bang-ups left more than 5,500 pieces of space junk to monitor and navigate.

Beyond SSA, there’s also progress in cyber cooperation. Rawat visited the US Cyber Command in Virginia — the first Indian senior official to do so — to discuss cyber tactics, now that India has a new Defence Cyber Agency charged with protecting infrastructure from attacks. But India also wants to be part of the secretive Cyber Offensive and Defensive Exercises (CODE) that the US hosts. Americans are receptive, but the two sides will have to sign an agreement before things can go forward. Invitations to CODE are hard to come by. But India’s case as a ‘frontline’ State is good.

The exercises are held every two years and, so far, only a few countries like Australia, the Czech Republic, Indonesia, Japan and Malaysia have participated, while six have been observers. The last CODE was in 2019, when for the first time the US decided to ‘co-host’ with Taiwan to send a signal. Teams of adversaries and friendlies battled in cyberspace to see who was up to snuff. The US Cyber Command does other exercises, including the annual Cyber Flag with foreign teams working with US civilian agencies to test preparedness for ever-evolving cyberthreats.

India and the US have also agreed for an Indian liaison officer of the rank of colonel or lieutenant colonel to be placed at the US Special Operations Command (USSOCOM) in Florida. The officer is expected to arrive within two months. The command is responsible for global operations against State and non-State actors, counterterrorism, hostage rescue, unconventional warfare and even foreign internal defence.

The strongest leg of the relationship remains defence cooperation, while trade and economic issues continue to be the weakest link. In a reversal of roles, India wants to do as many ‘feasible trade agreements’ — a take on free trade agreements (FTAs) — as possible. But Biden is not moving for fear of angering labour and environmental activists because trade policy is tangled up in his party’s factional politics. But why can’t the two sides at least talk and prepare the ground?
 

Indis-U.S. ties key to addressing global challenges: USIBC’s Nisha Desai Biswal​

Asserting that it is time for the trade relationship to grow in tandem with the centrality of India-US partnership, the head of a business advocacy organisation has said that the bilateral ties hold the key to addressing the most important challenges facing the world today.

“We’re at a phase now where our partnership is no longer characterised by just potential,” Nisha Desai Biswal, President of US India Business Council told PTI in an interview on Tuesday, November 16, 2021.

"In many ways, the US- India relationship holds the key to addressing the most important challenges facing the world today — from supply chain restructuring to climate change, to security objectives in the Indo-Pacific and world at large. It’s time for the trade relationship to grow in tandem with the centrality of our bilateral relationship,” she said.

Although US-India trade has grown steadily, from a mere USD 16 billion in 1999 to a more robust USD 146 billion in 2019, long-standing disagreements over critical issues and the lack of structural trade agreements between both countries have slowed attempts to realise the full perceived potential of the relationship, she noted, ahead of next week’s India visit of US Trade Representative Katherine Tai.

“We see this as an important moment to think bigger, and the TPF (Trade Police Forum) is the primary opportunity to cement a larger agenda. There is an urgency to this moment, with the supply chain crisis, India’s energy crisis, and the broader need for energy transition, it’s imperative that we expand the commercial relationship so we can make progress on all of these fronts,” Ms. Biswal said.

In response to a question, Ms. Biswal said business-friendly policies can unlock upwards of USD 200 billion in new trade over the next few years, as resolution of regulatory issues for both US and Indian companies opens the door for more expansive growth.

As leaders around the globe reconsider their approach to global trade and investment, both nations can and should do more to achieve the shared goal of USD 500 billion in two-way trade, she said.

Observing that the bilateral trade has grown nearly 10 times in the last 20 years – a phenomenal story of innovation and partnership, she acknowledged there are some key issues that remain.

Broader trade agenda​

India has promisingly shown a greater interest than ever before in a broader trade agenda, but some tariffs and regulatory policies continue to protect domestic industries rather than create the sort of predictable, investment-friendly landscape that multinationals feel comfortable making longer-run investments in, she said.

“Right now, we’re at a stage where both countries are interested in a broader trade relationship, but the US really wants to address those irritants first. India is going to be one of the world’s largest, youngest and fastest growing markets soon, so structurally, it’s extremely attractive and American and multinational firms want to be there,” she said.

“The US government wants an enabling environment for that to happen as it aligns with broader strategic goals, and the Indian government wants this to aid with development. So it’s important to recognise that more than differences, the present is characterised by potential alignment and opportunity. What’s needed at this point is a streamlined, and predictable regulatory environment on India’s part that can open the path forward,” Ms. Biswal said.

Ahead of Tai’s maiden India visit, she called for viewing trade as a key strategic issue for the United States, for both countries. If the administration wants to prove that democracies can come together at this time of geopolitical flux, strengthening trade and investment with the world’s largest democracy is an important place to start, she asserted.

“Even though the USTR may be going in with the intention of addressing these more specific barriers first, commitment to a larger agenda and holding a trade deal as the goal can encourage the frameworks and mood necessary to make real progress, rather than backsliding into an incrementalist approach which has consistently lagged behind the partnership’s importance,” she said.

USIBC, for quite some time, has been advocating for a Free Trade Agreement. To move forward toward a FTA, it’s really important that both countries do address the longstanding barriers, but in the context of a broader strategic frame, rather than in an insulated, piecemeal fashion, Biswal said.

“At this stage, it’s critical to find areas of consensus that can serve as stepping stones to a bigger deal. There are so many sectors with vast interdependencies where we can carve out modular agendas, and we should focus on the areas that we expect to drive growth in the future— like healthcare, and digital economy,” she added.

Responding to a question, she said although there remain concerns, the mood on India is optimistic.

“Again, structurally, India is an extremely attractive market and U.S. companies want to be in the country. Although regulatory predictability remains an issue, and industry is watching closely for developments in matters like Press Note 3 and guidelines for direct listing on India’s exchanges, the liberalising orientation of the current administration has been promising and has encouraged businesses to pay greater attention to India,” she noted.

The government's recent moves to raise FDI caps and especially to repeal the retroactive tax did a great deal to improve investor confidence and make U.S. companies more bullish on India, she said.

“Our members are excited about the overall trajectory; what’s really needed at this point is for the government to follow through with its expressed commitments to a consultative approach— our members want to be in India and they want to be in the policy conversation. In many ways that’s what we’re devoted to at the U.S.-India Business Council: enhancing the dialogue and expanding the forums for collaboration,” Ms. Biswal said.
 

US To Terminate Trade Retaliation Case Against India After Digital Tax Agreement​

The U.S. Trade Representative's office said on Wednesday it is moving to terminate its trade retaliation case against India after Washington and New Delhi agreed on a global tax deal transition arrangement that will withdraw India's digital services tax.

USTR said the agreement between the U.S. Treasury and India's Finance Ministry applies the same terms agreed to with Austria, Britain, France, Italy, Spain and Turkey, but with a slightly later implementation date.

The pact follows an October agreement by 136 countries in principle to withdraw their digital services taxes as part of a sweeping global tax deal agreed on Oct. 8 to adopt a 15 per cent global minimum corporate tax and grant some taxing rights on large profitable companies to market countries.

The countries agreed not to impose new digital services taxes before the OECD tax deal is implemented by the end of 2023, but arrangements needed to be made with seven countries that had existing digital taxes largely targeting U.S. technology giants including Google, Facebook and Amazon.com.

The deal between Washington and New Delhi brings all seven countries into a transition arrangement and came after U.S. Trade Representative Katherine Tai concluded a trip to India to discuss increasing trade cooperation on agricultural and other goods.

Under the agreed withdrawal terms, the countries can continue to collect digital services taxes until the new regime is put in place. But for Turkey and the European countries, any taxes collected after January 2022 that exceed what companies would have to pay under the new rules would be credited against the firms' future tax liabilities in those countries.

USTR said for India, the starting date for those credits was pushed back to April 1, 2022, with a three-month extension beyond the end of 2023 if the OECD tax deal is not implemented by that time.
 

India should free up exchange rate moves: U.S.​

India has been exemplary in publishing its foreign exchange market intervention, the U.S. Treasury Department said, adding that New Delhi should allow the exchange rate to move flexibly to reflect economic fundamentals.

“The (Indian) authorities should allow the exchange rate to move flexibly to reflect economic fundamentals, limit foreign exchange intervention to circumstances of disorderly market conditions, and refrain from further significant reserve accumulation,” it said.

“As the economic recovery progresses, the authorities should continue to pursue structural reforms that can help lift productivity and living standards, while supporting an inclusive and green recovery,” it said.

In its semi-annual report to Congress, the Treasury reviewed and assessed the policies of its major trading partners, comprising more than 80% of its foreign trade in goods and services, during the four quarters through June 2021.


According to the Treasury Department, India’s goods and services trade surplus with the U.S. was $40 billion over the four quarters through June 2021, a substantial increase from the relatively consistent level of about $30 billion from 2013 to 2019.
 

Deputy Secretary Sherman’s Call with Indian Foreign Secretary Shringla​

The following is attributable to Spokesperson Ned Price:


Deputy Secretary of State Wendy Sherman spoke with Indian Foreign Secretary Harsh Shringla today. They discussed a broad range of issues including Russia’s concerning military build-up on Ukraine’s borders and regional issues. Deputy Secretary Sherman and Foreign Secretary Shringla agreed to remain closely coordinated on shared goals and priorities and reiterated the importance of a strong U.S.-India partnership to mitigate the COVID-19 Omicron variant’s rapid advance.