From my very detached perspective, I feel that the Indian defense planning, procurement and development arms aren't super coordinated. What might seem logical to outside observers based on the geopolitics/economics is only sometimes the direction the Indian defense establishment moves in. I think this is the product of the various institutions and groups not having the full picture on the activities of the others, and so are not really able to plan in accordance. Internal politics also plays a part in it. From the very thread you linked you were talking about major publications on the mk2 that were a out of date by over a year...
The point being, anybody who is able to make sense on the inner workings of India's defense planning and procurement spends a lot of time thinking about what is feasible from whatever data is available, publicly or otherwise.
I was actually referring to how disingenous some of these people really are. Remember the HTT-40 discussions?
OT:
what is the reason Athos is being considered when there are so many domestic options on the table?
As mentioned before, there are none. ATAGS is still WIP, it needs to go through its last round of testing before it enters the LSP stage. This will take at least 2 years before the SP begins, so regiments will take at least 3-4 years before they get guns. Even after that it can only be used from some places, not all places, in the mountains. A new lighter ATAGS Mk2 needs to follow for mountain use.
The Dhanush is a clusterfuck, as usual, nothing surprising. Originally, all 114 guns were supposed to have been delivered by the end of 2022, not gonna happen. Not even 1 regiment is ready. The 52cal version is a post 2025 gun.
Bharat 52 is a WIP. It's suitable for mountains, but it needs to also go through the pretty long LSP stage before entering SP and into full regiment induction. It's quite a few years away before that happens.
Even after these guns are ready, the gunners need to complete their training and the guns themselves need to undergo exercises before they can be used in combat.
So, none of the indigenous options are still ready. It's a typical case of being more loyal than the king. The reality is simply different from expectations.
Based on the timeline of induction of all 400 ATHOS, all the guns will come in even before the first SP regiment of any indigenous 155/52mm gun is fully raised. Even with its fastest induction timeframe, it will still take 2 years from the start of contract before it can be used in battle.
As of today, the only artillery guns that have been tested and inducted since the artillery modernisation program began were both imports, the K9 and M777.
Frankly, we are horribly outclassed, we are going to have enough numbers for a limited war only by 2028 or so if we go through a fully indigenous route, considering all the guns clear trials over the next year. And people always forget that it's the artillery that wins wars.
This feels like the LUH/Ka-226 debacle again, where a domestic option will be ready to be procured in the same timeline as a similar import is made.
It's not a debacle. Two options were chosen for the fastest induction possible. Also, the Ka-226T isn't in the same class as the LUH. Arguments could have been made if the Fennec was selected, the LUH outclasses it. But the Ka-226T was selected not due to political reasons but because it's the only light helicopter specifically made for use in mountains. Its stability, ability to climb, safety etc are all in the class of medium helicopters for the price of a light helicopter. This was a conscious decision. Case in point, look at the safety record of the ALH/Mi-17 versus the Alouette III. Single-engine helicopters are not suitable for mountains and never will be.