Indian Economy : News,Discussions & Updates

Cut the bullshit !! i listened you the Modi's "Mere deshavasiyom" speech and he was talking all about capturing black money and nothing else. There was no word about Digitization or anything else.

Once that proven to be a flop, BJP media cell started pulling up theories like "Objective was secret", it was for "Digitization" excuse.
Do you know how much money was in circulation in notes? It was about 10 lakh crores excluding those in bank treasury or other govt agencies. Do you think these were all the black money involved? Black money is kept as export credit, asset, gold etc.

Demonetisation was a move for security and systemic reasons. The point here is that the real estate price can come down, prices of many otehr inflated things can come down etc.
 
Do you know how much money was in circulation in notes? It was about 10 lakh crores excluding those in bank treasury or other govt agencies. Do you think these were all the black money involved? Black money is kept as export credit, asset, gold etc.

Demonetisation was a move for security and systemic reasons. The point here is that the real estate price can come down, prices of many otehr inflated things can come down etc.

Again more bullshit straight out of BJP media cell. When the demobilisation was declared, the only objective declared was the capture of black money. The RBI expected less than 96% of the total money in circulation to return to the banks and their by taking out the rest 4% black money out of field. In reality, 99% of the money came back to the banks one way or another, making the entire demonitisation a disaster. At the top of that economy suffered,medium scale industries lost business and millions of jobs lost.

Regarding the reduction in real estate price, perhaps you need to look into how many builders went bankrupt in the last few years. The demand for real estate is low for many years,resulting in price going down, resulting in builders going bankrupt. There is an oversupply and builders cannot sell apartments even with very low price in metropolitan cities.

Indians just aren't buying new homes anymore
 
  • Agree
Reactions: Ashwin
Again more bullshit straight out of BJP media cell. When the demobilisation was declared, the only objective declared was the capture of black money. The RBI expected less than 96% of the total money in circulation to return to the banks and their by taking out the rest 4% black money out of field. In reality, 99% of the money came back to the banks one way or another, making the entire demonitisation a disaster. At the top of that economy suffered,medium scale industries lost business and millions of jobs lost.

Regarding the reduction in real estate price, perhaps you need to look into how many builders went bankrupt in the last few years. The demand for real estate is low for many years,resulting in price going down, resulting in builders going bankrupt. There is an oversupply and builders cannot sell apartments even with very low price in metropolitan cities.

Indians just aren't buying new homes anymore
Please tell me if Modi himself has given the exact objective. If not, you are bullshitting. I am not any BJP media cell person. Stop saying anything and everything. I too have searched a lot but could not find the actual statement by Modi of the objective. It was other ministers who spoke of it.
 
Again more bullshit straight out of BJP media cell. When the demobilisation was declared, the only objective declared was the capture of black money. The RBI expected less than 96% of the total money in circulation to return to the banks and their by taking out the rest 4% black money out of field. In reality, 99% of the money came back to the banks one way or another, making the entire demonitisation a disaster. At the top of that economy suffered,medium scale industries lost business and millions of jobs lost.

Regarding the reduction in real estate price, perhaps you need to look into how many builders went bankrupt in the last few years. The demand for real estate is low for many years,resulting in price going down, resulting in builders going bankrupt. There is an oversupply and builders cannot sell apartments even with very low price in metropolitan cities.

Indians just aren't buying new homes anymore
The term floated back then was "Massive Windfall Gains" And apparently no other ministers in NDA's government's cabinet has any credibility to what they have stated in past as De-Mo objectives.
 
we know there is black money, we have black money, we helped people to evade black money..

We failed the objective of Demonetization , why are we blaming Modi for ?

if at all anything, everything is brought to the books,

if any one gets caught hereafter, will find it difficult to escape.
 
we know there is black money, we have black money, we helped people to evade black money..

We failed the objective of Demonetization , why are we blaming Modi for ?

if at all anything, everything is brought to the books,

if any one gets caught hereafter, will find it difficult to escape.

Agree up to a point. The aim was good,there was black money, but they have succeeded in evading the goverment hands.
 
RBI likely to raise rates at Friday's review
The Reserve Bank is likely to increase the repo rate by 25 basis points in the upcoming monetary policy review as inflation is expected to accelerate further due to higher crude prices and the weakness in rupee. The monetary policy committee will start its three- day meeting from October 3 to decide on the fourth bi-monthly monetary policy.

After two successive hikes, the repo rate currently stands at 6.50 percent. "With petrol and diesel prices moving up, there is a strong expectation that inflation will also move up. So, they (RBI) may take a pre-emptive action. I feel there will be an increase of 25 basis points in the repo rate," Union Bank of India managing director and chief executive Rajkiran Rai G said.

Despite the rise in oil prices, the headline inflation number came down to 3.69 percent for August as against 4.17 percent for July. If the RBI increases repo rate by 25 basis points (bps), then it would be the third consecutive rate hike.

Experts says the weaker trend in the rupee may also prompt the central bank to raise repo rate. "Given where currency level is at this point of time, I think they will increase the interest rate by quarter basis points," HDFC vice chairman and chief executive Keki Mistry said. Tracking global developments, the rupee has become weak and is hovering around 73 against the dollar. The SBI, in its research report, Ecowrap, said the RBI should raise the policy repo rate at least 25 basis points to arrest the rupee's fall.

"We rule out a hike of 50 basis points, as it may spook the market. However, there is a probability of change in neutral stance too, as three successive rate hikes with a neutral stance could contradict RBI message," the research report said.

Morgan Stanley in a report said it expects the RBI to hike the short term rates at its October meeting. It said it remains bearish on the rupee despite the recent emerging market (EM) stabilisation as there are concerns about the recent default of a local financial institution, oil prices and a widening fiscal deficit persist.

"The default has led to a rise in corporate spreads and increases the refinancing pressure on domestic financial institutions at a time when our economist expects the RBI to hike at its October meeting," the Morgan Stanley report said.

A Kotak Economic Research report said the MPC will likely increase the repo rate by 25 bps in the October policy based on the implied impact of expected cyclical recovery in growth, rupee depreciation, and crude price movement on the medium term inflation trajectory. Bankers, however, do not expect the RBI to reduce cash reserve ratio (CRR), in the upcoming policy, despite liquidity condition remaining tight.

"The RBI has taken a few measures to ease the liquidity condition. I don't think they will reduce CRR," said a senior treasury official of a state-run bank.

After conducting two open market operations (OMOs), the apex bank Monday announced to conduct more such purchases to ease the liquidity condition in the banking system. Monday it announced a new OMO of Rs 36,000 crore.

"Based on an assessment of the durable liquidity needs going forward and the seasonal growth in currency in circulation observed in build-up to the festive season, we have decided to conduct purchase of government securities under OMOs worth Rs 36,000 crore in October 2018," the RBI said in a release Monday.
The auctions would be conducted during the second, third and fourth week of October, it said.
RBI likely to raise rates at Friday's review
 
India rivals China on inbound M&A for first time in a decade
For the first time in a decade India is giving its larger geopolitical rival China a run for its money in attracting foreign investment. The two countries are neck and neck on the volume of cash allotted this year from overseas mergers and acquisitions, representing what some experts call a counter-balance to an investment landscape in Asia that until recently favoured China.

In the first nine months of the year, China attracted $41.6bn in inbound M&A investment against India’s $40.6bn, according to data from Refinitiv. The boost in investment into India, which is up 64 per cent on the same period last year, has come as multinational corporations shift their outlook on the country’s domestic market from that of a poor, under-developed economy to one in which a rising middle class has started to generate and spend disposable income, say experts.

Much in the way that Chinese technology and ecommerce companies began attracting foreign investment several years ago, Indian companies such as ecommerce group Flipkart and payments company Paytm have been at the centre of India’s inbound investment boom. “Large, offline [consumer] players are starting to ask, ‘how do I make the Indian market relevant to me?’,” said Sonjoy Chatterjee, chairman of Goldman Sachs in India. “You are seeing a completely different theme in terms of technology and fintech.”

Not since 2008 have India and China attracted a similar level of foreign M&A investment. Between 2012 and 2016 China mustered at least double, sometimes triple, the level of inbound M&A attracted by India, whose deal volume fell to $8bn as recently as 2014. Walmart’s record-breaking acquisition of a $16bn stake in Flipkart bolstered the figure for India this year, while a $14bn fundraising round for payments group Ant Financial played a similar role for China.

Recommended beyondbrics Gaurav Dalmia India: good micro, worrying macro Warren Buffett, a longtime investor in Chinese companies such as battery and electric carmaker BYD, made his first large acquisition in India in August when his company Berkshire Hathaway agreed to invest $300m in Paytm. “In China, the technology sector is full-blown but in India it is still in a growth phase, maybe three to five years behind China,” said Ravi Kapoor, head of global banking at Citi in India, adding that the industry was attracting foreign investors looking for the same growth story experienced in China. China and India are at vastly different stages of development, but as they have opened to foreign investment since the 1990s, the two have drawn constant comparisons on economic achievement, growth and investment potential.

The trade war between the US and China, which is clouding China’s economic outlook, has turned the attention of some investors towards India as an alternative for investment in the region, said Reshmi Khurana, a Singapore-based managing director for business intelligence and investigations at Kroll. “With what’s happening with the trade war and the balance of geopolitical power in the region, India is seen as an alternative to China,” Ms Khurana said. For decades China and India have been geopolitical rivals. They fought a brief war in 1962 and have continued to clash on their shared 4,000km border.

With a gross domestic product of about $12.9tn, China’s economy was nearly five times that of India last year. However, India’s GDP grew by 7.7 per cent in the first quarter of 2018 and is expected to accelerate, while China’s growth rate is expected to decline over the next decade.
Subscribe to read | Financial Times
 
India facing economic crisis, says Nitin Gadkari blaming huge oil imports

Read more at:
India facing economic crisis, says Nitin Gadkari blaming huge oil imports - Times of India

@_Anonymous_ Is this first time India is importing oil?
Nope. But the GoI is fast running out of ideas & time. If you look at how day to day expenditure is met by the GoI, it's largely due to tax receipts on sales of oil derivatives - namely petrol & diesel, alcohol & real estate. This is mostly a Congress legacy, given their failure in ensuring a rules based regime & complicity in promoting tax evasion & sustaining a parallel economy.

In order to right this wrong, it'd take years of persistent efforts. That was one of the principal aims of demonetization.

Frankly, given our dependancy on oil & the reform mindedness of the incumbent PM, why couldn't we think of radical strategies like the odd / even one implemented in Delhi in the winters only on an all India basis ( I meant Tier - 1 cities initially followed by Tier - 2,3 &4 cities) , beginning with winter & gradually all around the year is beyond me.

I sense a dangerous drift out here with Modi relying solely on the TINA factor in all the forthcoming elections between now & next year end. All predictions, namely the incumbent Govt. mounting an offensive to reclaim PoK, Mandal -2, Ram Janmsbhoomi, etc are too late in the day for it to yield the desired results besides being fraught with danger.

It's TINA and the incremental benefits that schemes like complete rural electrification, enhanced LPG connections particularly in rural areas, loan waivers, better MSP, various beneficial schemes for women & the girl child, Swacch Bharat, etc provide its beneficiaries, with with the incumbent GoI will face the electorate.

P. S - never received the alert from your tag.
 
Last edited:
Again more bullshit straight out of BJP media cell. When the demobilisation was declared, the only objective declared was the capture of black money. The RBI expected less than 96% of the total money in circulation to return to the banks and their by taking out the rest 4% black money out of field. In reality, 99% of the money came back to the banks one way or another, making the entire demonitisation a disaster. At the top of that economy suffered,medium scale industries lost business and millions of jobs lost.

Regarding the reduction in real estate price, perhaps you need to look into how many builders went bankrupt in the last few years. The demand for real estate is low for many years,resulting in price going down, resulting in builders going bankrupt. There is an oversupply and builders cannot sell apartments even with very low price in metropolitan cities.

Indians just aren't buying new homes anymore

Demonetization was about monetizing banks because the economy was screwed up. When banks have money, black money is reduced. And future transactions will leave behind a paper trail, which was captured even better after connecting Aadhaar card and PAN card.
 
India facing economic crisis, says Nitin Gadkari blaming huge oil imports

Read more at:
India facing economic crisis, says Nitin Gadkari blaming huge oil imports - Times of India

@_Anonymous_ Is this first time India is importing oil?

India is also getting FDI and hence the net result of oil price hike is nullified to some extent. Gadkari may not be aware of many things in economy. Indian Sensex, rupee etc were all artificially inflated in 2017 due to some foreign investors over investing in India. There was no rationale for rupee going to 63.5 in 2017 from 68.5 in 2016 when crude oil price was increasing fast. The sensex also went to 39000 due to over-investment.

The true level of sensex rises according to Indian growth level. So, reaching 39000 was unwarranted. The real level of rupee is 74 and that of sensex 35000 going by the inflation difference of India and the world and the growth of Indian economy. The levels have come down to real levels. if it decline further, only then one has to worry.
 
India facing economic crisis, says Nitin Gadkari blaming huge oil imports

Read more at:
India facing economic crisis, says Nitin Gadkari blaming huge oil imports - Times of India

@_Anonymous_ Is this first time India is importing oil?

India has been coming under pressure from oil exporters and the automobile industry to slow down our alternate fuels and electric car plans.

So the govt is using the media to threaten OPEC to reduce prices or risk losing market share over the long term, while also signalling the car makers about what's coming next, with the announcement of an electric plan in August along with a significant subsidy for electric cars.

Government plans new policy to promote electric vehicles

Boost for electric vehicles: Government plans to offer Rs 1.4 lakh subsidy

By taking everything public from the highest offices, the govt is making their intentions clear.
 
  • Like
Reactions: _Anonymous_
Frankly, given our dependancy on oil & the reform mindedness of the incumbent PM, why couldn't we think of radical strategies like the odd / even one implemented in Delhi in the winters only on an all India basis ( I meant Tier - 1 cities initially followed by Tier - 2,3 &4 cities) , beginning with winter & gradually all around the year is beyond me.

Most cities have inadequate public transportation.
 
Nope. But the GoI is fast running out of ideas & time. If you look at how day to day expenditure is met by the GoI, it's largely due to tax receipts on sales of oil derivatives - namely petrol & diesel, alcohol & real estate. This is mostly a Congress legacy, given their failure in ensuring a rules based regime & complicity in promoting tax evasion & sustaining a parallel economy.

In order to right this wrong, it'd take years of persistent efforts. That was one of the principal aims of demonetization.

Frankly, given our dependancy on oil & the reform mindedness of the incumbent PM, why couldn't we think of radical strategies like the odd / even one implemented in Delhi in the winters only on an all India basis ( I meant Tier - 1 cities initially followed by Tier - 2,3 &4 cities) , beginning with winter & gradually all around the year is beyond me.

I sense a dangerous drift out here with Modi relying solely on the TINA factor in all the forthcoming elections between now & next year end. All predictions, namely the incumbent Govt. mounting an offensive to reclaim PoK, Mandal -2, Ram Janmsbhoomi, etc are too late in the day for it to yield the desired results besides being fraught with danger.

It's TINA and the incremental benefits that schemes like complete rural electrification, enhanced LPG connections particularly in rural areas, loan waivers, better MSP, various beneficial schemes for women & the girl child, Swacch Bharat, etc provide its beneficiaries, with with the incumbent GoI will face the electorate.

P. S - never received the alert from your tag.
There are certain limits on how things work. There is no magic wand to do things. There is congress legacy of doing things but there is also one more factor - foreign investments. Last year India received $20 billion dollar investment in bonds of India by foreign countries as political favour. The whole Indian growth is fueled by political favours of foreign countries towards India to avoid war like scenario. Ultimately, it is the Ram Mandir and Dharma that is the true core issue, not economy. To avoid Modi from going the path of core issues, India will get FDI even this year to keep Indian forex reserves high enough. The LPG drive etc are also funded by the same FDI. Otherwise, ask yourself as to how can India fund such massive increase in consumption.

The solution of odd and even is bad as it reduces Indian industry and growth Automobile sales is indeed needed to increase growth. Similarly, unnecessarily restricting oil imports will also hurt growth. Why should India limit growth unnecessarily when it can get FDI? India is not even going for coal liquefaction as

Modi is not just relying on TINA but also on the core issue and mobilisation of people at ground level. Most opposition is funded by foreign countries and hence any misdeeds by them will be met with strictly. BJP has made a clear condition that to not raise core issue, the main condition is that none of the opposition will be funded by foreign countries and that India must get sufficient FDI for growth. In this case, the situation created is that only BJP can win elections and also the country will grow, all the while, the core issues will be postponed. This is not dangerous trend but the strategy itself.


India has been coming under pressure from oil exporters and the automobile industry to slow down our alternate fuels and electric car plans.

So the govt is using the media to threaten OPEC to reduce prices or risk losing market share over the long term, while also signalling the car makers about what's coming next, with the announcement of an electric plan in August along with a significant subsidy for electric cars.

Government plans new policy to promote electric vehicles

Boost for electric vehicles: Government plans to offer Rs 1.4 lakh subsidy

By taking everything public from the highest offices, the govt is making their intentions clear.
Just because India is trying to boost EV does not mean that India can reduce fossil fuel. The only substitute for oil is coal liquefaction, not renewable energy. There is a reason why none are using renewable energy till now. The battery of lithium, solar, wind, hydel etc existed since 1980s. There was never a need for any country to rely on Arab oil at all. USA faced sanctions from Arabs in 1973 and after that made petro-dollar deal because of which other countries were forced to use dollars. If renewables were so simple to use, they would already be in use instead of struggling to get oil and between sanctions.

Renewable energy is simply eyewash. Don't take it seriously
 
Most cities have inadequate public transportation.
Shouldn't the emphasis be on increasing mass rapid transport systems then? Besides, I advocated a graduated approach. The implementation ought to be in a phased manner and tested on the ground before one includes Tier - 2 cities. I don't see any problems with covering the major metros within say the next 3-4 years.