Have been watching some YouTube videos of exmuslims like Sahil and Adam seeker, don’t know how it popped up in my recommendation. After watching dozens of videos I realised
> Deradicalistation done by IA or state police is one of the biggest fraud carried on taxpayers money.
Depends on where it's carried out . If you're referring to Kashmir , there's been a long standing demand to tackle the JeI there which has been at the roots of the separatist movement there . It's only now that it's been achieved by cutting their funding sources , preventing their employment in government jobs & sacking those who're active there , proscribing their preachings to some extent without a full ban on them thru curbs etc.
It's basically what I refer to as a difference between the Dulat line & the Doval line . Dudat has just given a series of interviews to promote his latest book & has been b*tching about Doval a lot . Connect the dots & read in between the lines . Check out his interview with Karan Thapar . You'd get the drift.
> Maulvis and Molanas wield all the power as more than 90% Muslims don’t know Arabic.
Yes. All muslims learn the Koran by rote . The language is archaic Arabic which is unintelligible to the modern arabic speaker too unless he's been trained in it .
It may come as a surprise to you that even upto the graduate level in Madrassahs they aren't taught the exegesis of the Koran .
In fact their true study of it , in great depth happens only in their equivalent of the masters degree in modern education .
> Lack/suppression of knowledge of own religion is mixed with malpractices in other religions to make a complete package of superiority i.e, Zakir Naik’s modus operandi.
Include suppression of the malpractices of their own in it . Basically Islam itself is for by & of people who believe in conquests & loot. It succeeded upto the 16th century when they controlled vast parts of Asia upto India SE Asia & the habitable parts of Africa where 3 of the premier Empires in the world belonged to them viz the Ottomans , the Safavids & the Mughals.
With the advent of the Europeans who with their emphasis on universal education , a scientific spirit , a will for exploration & risk taking along with the benefits of science & technology out gunned the Muslims in the art of looting & empire building. They haven't recovered since & by the looks of it won't recover this century as well .
(Pakistan is a good example of this . These empires existed for the benefit of a small elite with the rest meant to serve those elites. As long as the scope for conquest & loot existed , Pakistan would've thrived. Since it doesn't , Pakistan bis where it is today . Ditto for Afganistan. )
A good example would be the oil sheikhdoms of the Gulf . They could establish the finest universities there promoted universal education , encouraged science & technology drives by their population yet have they ? And in the next 2-3 decades oil & gas particularly the former wil lose its importance & consequently it's currency in geo poltics.
Discussion gives a core for understanding basic psychology of Paxtanis and Muslims in general.
@_Anonymous_
An anecdote :
An apocryphal story goes that when Hulegu Khan grandson of Chinggis Khan captured Baghdad & had the last Abbasid Caliph presented before him , he asked him to explain in one line the essence of Islam without which Islam wouldn't survive.
The story goes on to say the Caliph replied - it's the will of Allah . In which case I can have your head cut off as Allah wishes it , Hulegu responded .
What about order in the universe - Hulegu asked . The Caliph affirmed - yes it's important . In that case , if a kafir can ensure order over a Muslim in a province whose rule would be superior ? asked Hulegu . The Caliph responded - the Kafir's.
Hulegu thanked him & had him crushed to death rolled in carpets by the hooves of horses since the Mongols believed spilling of royal blood in any land they occupied was inauspicious & a sign of destruction to come.
That's precisely the policy China's following without explicitly stating it to be so .
My point is left to their own devices Muslims would neither be modernised nor would they assimilate . The story of the 54 muslim majority nations is before you , most 90% + Muslims in terms of demographics with their religious minorities living in the same manner as dhimmis were in the bygone days . Yet there's grave strife in their societies.
The only exception to these can be Turkey & Iran with Bangladesh , Egypt & Indonesia as outliers in the mid to long term for which they need a lot of working to at least build a platform from where they can launch themselves .
I've no hope for any other Muslim nation particularly the Arab nations.