Shivalik Class (Project 17 A/B) & Talwar Class Frigates

INS Nilgiri successfully started firing trials along with its ongoing sea trials:



1725294894763.png

1725295014256.png

No gun installed yet. We saw INS Surat head out for sea trials with an older 76mm gun as well. Some problem at BHEL Haridwar plant?
 
  • Like
Reactions: Rajput Lion
Unit costs should drop below the $1bn mark imo, once we start localizing the radar and weapons fit on our upcoming DDG/FFG/corvettes.

Since electronics and weapons constitute >60% of the cost of naval ships.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Rajput Lion
Glad to note that the NCG is projected as a 5000t class ship. Should be a perfect replacement for the Talwars and Brahmaputras in due course.

In fact, we should extend the NGC production run to 8+10+3 imo so that we won't be stuck if Zorya Mashproekt, the Ukranian engine-manufacturer goes up in smoke.

Also, it's more cost effective to buy new NCGs rather than re-engine the Brahmaputra class. Those ladies have earned their rest.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Rajput Lion
  • Like
Reactions: South block, vampyrbladez, randomradio and 3 others
Gautam said:
INS Tushil with a Ka-28 on the heli pad at JSC Yantar Shipyard. Pics from Sep 27:
View attachment 37685

INS Tamala hiding behind another vessel:
View attachment 37684
Click to expand...

This is a thoroughly outdated design by modern standards.

With all the delays in construction, they make even less sense today if you ask me.

Imo the IN should have towed the unfinished hulls to MDL or another local yard years ago for outfitting when the Ukr war broke out.

The Batch 1 and 2 Talwars are slated to get Elta-2258+MRSAM during MLU anyway.

These new vessels could have been commissioned with those systems fitted.
 
Speedster1 said:
This is a thoroughly outdated design by modern standards.

With all the delays in construction, they make even less sense today if you ask me.

Imo the IN should have towed the unfinished hulls to MDL or another local yard years ago for outfitting when the Ukr war broke out.

The Batch 1 and 2 Talwars are slated to get Elta-2258+MRSAM during MLU anyway.

These new vessels could have been commissioned with those systems fitted.
Click to expand...
Cost and delivery speed were in mind when we signed for this. Godavri frigates were out and P17A was some time away.
 
  • Like
Reactions: YoungWolf
No need to buy anymore from outside..... P 17A frigate & P 15 design are aesthetic as hell & has become a jealousy point for many warship aesthetic enthusiast foreigners....... Little bit change & a good amount of refinement is needed & we probably have the most bad a** looking warship design anywhere on the planet.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Rajput Lion
Ankit Kumar said:
Cost and delivery speed were in mind when we signed for this. Godavri frigates were out and P17A was some time away.
Click to expand...
It may be relatively cheaper to a P-17A but no comparison is terms of capability. Though there are some upgrades over previous batches like the Oto 76mm gun, Scatter SSR, etc, the AD suite is 80s vintage.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Top Bottom