Sukhoi Su-30MKI

This clubbing of deals has happened before. When the 2012 MKI contract for 42 was clubbed with Mi-17, people assumed the higher price was because it was a Super Sukhoi version with all new avionics. Some even assumed these are nuclear versions for the SFC, which later the IAF denied. Some even assumed it was cost gouging as people are claiming for this time as well. It was only sometime later that we got to know the deal included 151 Mi-17s.

During the visit of the Russian President Vladimir Putin to India in December2012, a contract for additional 42 Su-30MKIs was signed. According to onereport, the total cost of these 42 fighters is estimated to be around $4.3 billion,as these are expected to have better specifications. Rumour has it that theseadditional aircraft were specially configured for nuclear delivery and were to costless than those produced by HAL.

It was $4.5B. And almost $3B went into the Mi-17s.

This time there was a theory that these 12 were some sort of specialized EW aircraft, which is still possible in some ways. Some theorized that it's necessary for a new production line, which is what Ankit is referring to. But the IAF is not interested in more MKIs, due to oversupply, and it's still too early to invest for export.

63000 Cr is the size of the MLU program, not the contract size with Russia. This deal could have elements of whatever's needed from Russia for the MLU. We could assume half is for the MKIs and the other half for MLU. Perhaps a ToT deal for the spares and maintenance of MKIs that were not part of the initial contract. We did the same for the T-90 in 2019; $3.12B for 464 tanks and new technologies, but $1.2B of that was ToT. Or it pays for some new Russian technology they would like to keep secret; ie, specialized EW aircraft.

This is pretty common with deals with Russia. Even our leased SSNs show a different sticker price compared to its actual cost. The first one was less than $700M, the second sub was les than $1B. But the contract prices were $2.5B and $3B resply.

So this deal too is just history repeating itself.
This is not a deal with russia but HAL. Its written on the document which is visible.

What does an old misreporting have to do with this deal? Assumptions don't make sense.
 
Any chance for further increase? This one is the finest artillery existing today.

Beyond 300, I don't know, but there is requirement for more considering the number of armored brigades. It may end with 300 because an FRCV based SPH could fulfill the rest when that comes along. So 15 regiments (300) of K9 and perhaps 10 regiments of a new design.
 
This is not a deal with russia but HAL. Its written on the document which is visible.

What does an old misreporting have to do with this deal? Assumptions don't make sense.

Yeah, since it's with HAL, the deal will be MKI-centric. This is a lot more similar to the T-90 deal. So either new tech or some additional ToT. But it also means HAL will sign whatever's necessary with Russia. MoD is merely introducing a middle man.

MKI's indigenization is currently at 57%. This deal is said to increase that to 67%. So makes sense that this deal comes with that additional 10%. And the IAF's goal is to sign all the deals necessary to bring as close to 100% as possible the MRO of all of their jets as per what they announced a few years ago.

Simply put, this deal is 12 MKIs plus something else.
 
Yeah, since it's with HAL, the deal will be MKI-centric. This is a lot more similar to the T-90 deal. So either new tech or some additional ToT. But it also means HAL will sign whatever's necessary with Russia. MoD is merely introducing a middle man.

MKI's indigenization is currently at 57%. This deal is said to increase that to 67%. So makes sense that this deal comes with that additional 10%. And the IAF's goal is to sign all the deals necessary to bring as close to 100% as possible the MRO of all of their jets as per what they announced a few years ago.

Simply put, this deal is 12 MKIs plus something else.
Tbh its not middle man, rather HAL would be making those from scratch. Huge difference, yes the materials many of the volume will be imported but what Govt wanted always is local production under ToT/licensing and part local sourcing only. This part is the policymakers will, HAL merely there to facilitate that.
 
  • Agree
Reactions: Rajput Lion
Tbh its not middle man, rather HAL would be making those from scratch. Huge difference, yes the materials many of the volume will be imported but what Govt wanted always is local production under ToT/licensing and part local sourcing only. This part is the policymakers will, HAL merely there to facilitate that.

I'm not sure about it being made from scratch, just kit assembly. We don't have access to the landing gear, it was built in Russia to cut costs, so that's where I think we may have received some ToT, so (correction) 62.5%.

Anyway, this deal increasingly looks like it's connected to the MLU program. Russia's providing some tech and that's part of the upgrade contract.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Rajput Lion
The latest batch will have indigenous content of ~62%, so far away from MLU target of near 80%.

Anyways, as I said earlier, re-opening the production line for 12 jets is simply asinine. Even the Americans didn't do it for F-22 because of cost escalations. So I hope we end up ordering 50-70 more, but of course, in UPG. configuration.
 
  • Like
Reactions: YoungWolf
The latest batch will have indigenous content of ~62%, so far away from MLU target of near 80%.

Anyways, as I said earlier, re-opening the production line for 12 jets is simply asinine. Even the Americans didn't do it for F-22 because of cost escalations. So I hope we end up ordering 50-70 more, but of course, in UPG. configuration.

Climbing up from 57 or 58% to 62.5% is of greater consequence on the standard MKI 'cause it's composed of tech that was earlier denied by Russia. The increase by replacing the radar and other Russian and Israeli avionics is just a bonus that's within our control. At 78%, it would mean all the non-Indian stuff being replaced would represent 15.5% of the total cost. The second phase could achieve a higher percentage, but hopefully by then we will have full control over the airframe and avionics. After all, the MKI still has 40-50 years left in the IAF.
 
The latest batch will have indigenous content of ~62%, so far away from MLU target of near 80%.

Anyways, as I said earlier, re-opening the production line for 12 jets is simply asinine. Even the Americans didn't do it for F-22 because of cost escalations. So I hope we end up ordering 50-70 more, but of course, in UPG. configuration.

We won't do it for just 12 I think..

Maybe like the Su 30 engines ( 2 numbers were immediately delivered after getting signed)
We also already made parts and assembling them would be done entirely in a year if it's old configuration or more likely in small batches in UPG configuration for testing & certifying Su 30 UPG .
 
  • Agree
Reactions: Rajput Lion
If the airframe undergoes significant weight reduction (due to lighter radar, avionics, composites, etc), Sukhoi will likely need to modify the FCS.

Otherwise, we should see a wholesale swapping out of Russian gear with local systems including mission computer, radar processors, etc.

Apart from the Sigma-95N INS/GPS, everything French is also likely on the way out. MFDs, for example. Except we might integrate the same Thales IFF that's on the MiG-29UPG.

Remains to be seen if the chunky Israeli (ElOp) HUD gets replaced by a sleek digital one.

I'd love to see all the dial pointer instruments and flip switches in the cockpit gone. Our MKI pilots need a cleaner 'office' to work out of.
 
Edit: Any idea why the Su-35/Su-30SM2/Su-57 series have 2× large displays versus just 1 LAD? Would it be technically feasible to add a scaled variant of the LCA Mk2 LAD to MKI UPG?
 
Yeah, since it's with HAL, the deal will be MKI-centric. This is a lot more similar to the T-90 deal. So either new tech or some additional ToT. But it also means HAL will sign whatever's necessary with Russia. MoD is merely introducing a middle man.

MKI's indigenization is currently at 57%. This deal is said to increase that to 67%. So makes sense that this deal comes with that additional 10%. And the IAF's goal is to sign all the deals necessary to bring as close to 100% as possible the MRO of all of their jets as per what they announced a few years ago.

Simply put, this deal is 12 MKIs plus something else.
Yes, there could be additional content due to the additional localization. That doesn't mean it's part of MLU.
 
Astra Rafael Comsys received Rs.255.88 crores order from Ministry of Defence.

Orders are worth an aggregate amount of Rs. 255 crores for the supply of 93 additional sets of Software Defined Radios (SDR) LRUs with A kits, SBC 2 card, and Network Centric Operations application for the Su-30 MKI fighter aircraft.

Air%20Large%20verson-1.jpg