Status
Not open for further replies.
Sir in case you read the News that I posted above , Army And IAF commanders are meeting on 8 th and 11 th April

To discuss ongoing operations and Operational preparedness

This clearly means that Things have been
Happening for the last one month


Sir.

Things have been happening, no one is denying. But the same is calibrated. It is not as if we have taken over large tracts of territory. The hemorrhaging is heavy for the opposite side .. always was the intent since the initial, when I had to tell you that war will not be fought.

Although Pakistan is more than welcome to try.

The basic problem for PA this time round is that till date, every GoI had stuck to Shimla Agreement, which made LC sacrosanct. Even PM Modi was willing to give peace a chance under it. But the actions of our neighbour at Gurdaspur and Pathankot, put paid to it. Pulwama was teh final nail, IAF crossing was indication of LC being rendered to history. That day forward, the GoI decided that LC is CFL of 1948, not a sacrosanct border. But it took time to build the diplomatic capability to actually enforce it. And now, the same is being enforced.

All along LC, save a location or two here and there, PA is at a lower height and IA dominates them. In one odd sector we are at a slightly disadvantageous position, and we suffer because of that at times too.

In Mendhar, for example, the villages are quite near to LC, so was easy for them to slip cadres in. But with expansion of strike envelope granted to local commanders, the same is no more an advantage for pushing in proxy.

What you are seeing is the simple outcome of Indians dominating from heights and maintaining a volume of fire that the PA simply have no option but to vacate. Now posts are usually made in a way that another of own side, provides cover to it (read: can engage it if it falls in enemy hands) hence, the problem for capturing troops is that the momentum has to be maintained. And with that, few tactically important positions have been taken/alternate points on the contiguous ridges established, which are making life difficult for remaining Pakistani troops in the area.

Interesting few days ahead. You can look forward to more such indications - of a number of positions occupied/destroyed by India.
 
Sir with utmost respect , I would say that
There is a Concept called " Need to Know "
Basis , for Information sharing In the military

I dont think all these details are being even
Disseminated freely in the Army hierarchy

These Anonymous twitter accounts
Are only Replacing Mainstream Media
And countering the Enemy Psy Ops

Even then they are followed by hardly 5000 people

The Rest of the Country thinks that the Match ended on 27 Feb


Sir

Precisely. they have their own agenda. I agree. Quite a few of their claims are deadly accurate, few, not. The intent remains to post data that is verifiable or not verifiable. Not make claims based on their say so.

It is easy to spell out things right now, but I would rather that the GoI spells it out or Military Forces, otherwise it becomes a case of little knowledge is dangerous.

Just yesterday, on twitter, the case of mother of Maj Girish (who was Killed in Action at Nagrota) was being mainstreamed by Shiv Aroor, Neeraj Rajput, Major Gaurav Arya among others. It took me a whole day to convince at least 5 fellow citizens that Army knows exactly what happens and awards are decided by Armed Forces' Honours & Awards Committee made of Armed Forces members and canvassing Politician to upgrade award is politicization of armed forces with next stop being every award to be quota based (state based?)

Maj Gaurav Arya was contacted by me on DM and his rationale, although sound, was pointed out to be flawed in military terms by yours truly. And I believe he has not ventured in that field today, after last night Army review committee took a relook and decided that award of Mention in Dispatches is correct and mother was unhappy and launched a petition for withdrawal of the same and no award. Again getting support from civil reporters.

It is that situation, wherein politicization of every aspect of military operations happens, over claims that media assumes to be true and then Armed Forces are either unwilling to prove/disprove the veracity of same or simply can not. Hence, my attempt to correct perceptions here, so that no exaggeration is mainstreamed. Members here are active on twitter, and I would not like to see things being trumped up to denote what is incorrect.
 
Well yes. There have been futher attacks on Indian armed forces after 27th.
Looks like you dont check the news?
If India was that powerful as you are portraying, they should hav launched another attack? They did not?
Also your western air space is shut since 27th and still shut..
Now who is scared of whom?
Chacha bhaang chane ho kya?

Ahmedabad, Mumbai all having more air traffic than your entire failed country.

Live Flight Tracker - Real-Time Flight Tracker Map | Flightradar24

View attachment 5634
He is confused, can't differentiate between Indian territory and Pakistans.
 
Maybe they are as Jingoistic as PDF and believes they can mobilize their corps once they notice out Strike corps on the move. I assume Moving their corps is not easy on resources, men, spares, fuel and money. So Saving as much as they possibly can.


Hmmm. But they have already moved all they could. Now they will move PDFians with guns as next line .... ;)

There were a few who were prepared to walk immediately with their weapons from UK ... I assume they have learnt how to walk on water and reach Pakistan by foot in 24 hours.
 
Hmmm. But they have already moved all they could. Now they will move PDFians with guns as next line .... ;)

There were a few who were prepared to walk immediately with their weapons from UK ... I assume they have learnt how to walk on water and reach Pakistan by foot in 24 hours.
Rouhani Taqat hain, seconds main pahoonch saktay hain.
 
Hmmm. But they have already moved all they could. Now they will move PDFians with guns as next line .... ;)

There were a few who were prepared to walk immediately with their weapons from UK ... I assume they have learnt how to walk on water and reach Pakistan by foot in 24 hours.

Let us hope we capture Oscar and Windy

I would like to meet and greet them
 
@vstol Jockey @Falcon

Some years back , one guy wrote a fictional short story about India Pak War

Towards the end the same thing happened

The Elite Ran away with their families , expecting Nuclear war

This is a distinct possibility
 
As I have come to understand over the past few weeks, there are two kinds of rabble rousers in defence forums:

The first kind who are way over optimistic and believe our forces have punched through into Skardu and Afganistan. They are the ones swallowing whatever social media is tossing up without any effort at fact checking.

The second kind of snowflake who have toured a few non Indian defence forums, taken in hook line and sinker the kool aid propaganda and believe that India's face has been kicked in. These are the ones wailing that India needs to go to war and crush Bajwa's neck with bare hands, while taking a UHD 3-D Livestream with comments enabled of course, so that they can win their little arguments against Pakistanis on online forums.

One post wailing about how he can't win his argument against Pakistanis because govt won't feed him classified proof to another one declaring Fateh over a Promotion of an officer of PAk MEA.

Truly a theatre of the bizzare.
 
As I have come to understand over the past few weeks, there are two kinds of rabble rousers in defence forums:

The first kind who are way over optimistic and believe our forces have punched through into Skardu and Afganistan. They are the ones swallowing whatever social media is tossing up without any effort at fact checking.

The second kind of snowflake who have toured a few non Indian defence forums, taken in hook line and sinker the kool aid propaganda and believe that India's face has been kicked in. These are the ones wailing that India needs to go to war and crush Bajwa's neck with bare hands, while taking a UHD 3-D Livestream with comments enabled of course, so that they can win their little arguments against Pakistanis on online forums.

One post wailing about how he can't win his argument against Pakistanis because govt won't feed him classified proof to another one declaring Fateh over a Promotion of an officer of PAk MEA.

Truly a theatre of the bizzare.


Kargil conflict was much simpler

We got the Same briefing Everyday
For more than a month
 
Kargil conflict was much simpler

We got the Same briefing Everyday
For more than a month

BRF had to close down their forum through the conflict because of the amount of rumors, false Intel and sheer blind guesswork by the participants. Some of the oldies in BRF will be able to tell you better.

It was no better than today. Just that information then had it's own speed.
 
BRF had to close down their forum through the conflict because of the amount of rumors, false Intel and sheer blind guesswork by the participants. Some of the oldies in BRF will be able to tell you better.

It was no better than today. Just that information then had it's own speed.
I remember a picture of tortured corpse of a jawan was put up. That was crossing the line for many memebers then.
 
  • Informative
Reactions: DivineHeretic
BRF had to close down their forum through the conflict because of the amount of rumors, false Intel and sheer blind guesswork by the participants. Some of the oldies in BRF will be able to tell you better.

It was no better than today. Just that information then had it's own speed.

Internet was a Rarity in 1999
People used it only for E mail
 
Status
Not open for further replies.