Status
Not open for further replies.
Is it not in our national interest and security to desire independent Sindhudesh, Balochdesh and Pakhtunwadesh :unsure:

And "for all the actions needed under "humanitarian" heading" - are we heading in the right direction with the triple talaq to begin with?

For 1st half, not in my personal opinion.

For 2nd, yes. That is where we need to concentrate our efforts. Consolidation of society into an unified one which takes multireligious set up in India as an added feather in cap & not as a strong foundation. Human & resource management is next.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Golden_Rule
But this is where our western neighbor is headed towards.

That again, is their problem. We need not stop it, if that be the case. If our security interests at that point of time require us to enable the process, so be it. At present, I don't see any gain. Except POJ&K which I anyways take to be core interest of ours.
 
I wonder how long will this continue though? There are already reports that in view of the heavily fortified LoC, the PA / ISI duo have shifted infiltration to Punjab. What's to prevent them from shifting it further south to Rajasthan & Gujarat in the near to long term future. Given that they've eschewed an open war, with the easing of restrictions in Kashmir, we are bound to see a backlash there. It could potentially translate in intensification of the insurgency there and a possible spread across the mainland manifesting in spectacular strikes.Apart from this, there are other fault lines for the PA / ISI to probe across India. Any insight on how are we going to manage this intensification of hybrid warfare across the country, a Conventional Balakote type response not withstanding & assuming it'd end just as inconclusively like it did on 27th February.


Precisely. As the situation evolves, so shall our security imperatives. At this point of time, it is not conducive for us. Too many variables at play still
 
You mean we still haven't gamed for such a scenario.

Planning and working out situations is quite different from execution and implementation of the same. We have catered to a fragmented, fanatical western front on our borders and we have catered to a strong central government in Pakistan able to exert its will across fanatics.
 
  • Informative
Reactions: _Anonymous_
A rouge and brutal regime in our western border will always be harmful for us. Maybe all those persecutions are ' none of our buissness ' but surely we could use them as a reason to strike and destroy Pakistan because frankly speaking the very existence of Pakistan is now not in our interest even it is constantly putting adverse effects on them.


No. We are not even concerned about them and their system as long as it does not affect our way of life, our security and our interests.
 
as long as it does not affect our way of life, our security and our interests.
Really??? Do you know how much have lost due to this ongoing violence. According to RTI our 4506 or so soldiers attained veergati due to CFVs from 2003 to now. According to a report we would have been a 3.5 trillion dollar economy in 2017 itself if there were no violence in Kashmir and naxal areas. But we achieved on 2.6 trillion mark solely due to these conflicts incited by Pakistan. That is a loss of 900 billion dollars. So if you are saying that 4506 casualties and loss of 900 billion dollars " does not affect our way of life, our security and our interest" then Sir I must presume you are the only person having this conviction.
 
What's to prevent them from shifting it further south to Rajasthan & Gujarat in the near to long term future.
Their ethnicity will give them away forget police local people will give them nice welcome in other states. In J&K they survive as they can hide, mix up a bit and more importantly not get outed in some areas where separatists makes money.

In Rajasthan and Punjab badi kutai honi hai inki.

Did LOC heat up too much last night to welcome Bajwa? SMQ called a panicky presser at mid night.
 
Their ethnicity will give them away forget police local people will give them nice welcome in other states. In J&K they survive as they can hide, mix up a bit and more importantly not get outed in some areas where separatists makes money.

In Rajasthan and Punjab badi kutai honi hai inki.
Their modus operandi will be unlike what they attempt in Kashmir. It'd be more on the lines of a Pathankot Or a 26/11.
 
  • Like
Reactions: BlackOpsIndia
Really??? Do you know how much have lost due to this ongoing violence. According to RTI our 4506 or so soldiers attained veergati due to CFVs from 2003 to now. According to a report we would have been a 3.5 trillion dollar economy in 2017 itself if there were no violence in Kashmir and naxal areas. But we achieved on 2.6 trillion mark solely due to these conflicts incited by Pakistan. That is a loss of 900 billion dollars. So if you are saying that 4506 casualties and loss of 900 billion dollars " does not affect our way of life, our security and our interest" then Sir I must presume you are the only person having this conviction.
Add to this over 70k deaths of civilians in Pak sponsored terrorism in Punjab and Kashmir and bomb blasts in other parts of India. The extreme security set up that we have nearly everywhere costs us over 100k crores every year. All this is due to Pakistan.
 
Their modus operandi will be unlike what they attempt in Kashmir. It'd be more on the lines of a Pathankot Or a 26/11.
They still have to cross border villages, life is very routine in those interior area. Not many outsiders visit them, odd ones will be filtered out in buffer zones.

Mumbai was different, they came via sea with little human contact and that too in a cosmopolitan mixup.
 
Planning and working out situations is quite different from execution and implementation of the same. We have catered to a fragmented, fanatical western front on our borders and we have catered to a strong central government in Pakistan able to exert its will across fanatics.

I'm not convinced by the explanation. The Pentagon even has CONOP 8888. :p
 
They still have to cross border villages, life is very routine in those interior area. Not many outsiders visit them, odd ones will be filtered out in buffer zones.

Mumbai was different, they came via sea with little human contact and that too in a cosmopolitan mixup.
Have you been to Kutch ? Please go there. You'd understand what I'm referring to. The security there is minimal and there's a thriving market for smugglers. In fact thriving is an understatement, you've mini ships and dhows from Porbander making rendezvous with their Pakistani numbers mid sea. And Porbander is in Saurashtra.What's more, all this is an open secret. With everyone from the local constabulary to the bureaucrats to the politicians on the take.
 
Have you been to Kutch ? Please go there. You'd understand what I'm referring to. The security there is minimal and there's a thriving market for smugglers. In fact thriving is an understatement, you've mini ships and dhows from Porbander making rendezvous with their Pakistani numbers mid sea. And Porbander is in Saurashtra.What's more, all this is an open secret. With everyone from the local constabulary to the bureaucrats to the politicians on the take.
That's all the reason not to let that thriving market go down by helping terrorists. Single incident and all that business will be finished, they keep extra vigilance for such events.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.