Pakistan Economy : Updates and Discussions

So like middle-income trap, is there a low-income trap ?
Nothing like that but if you are hell bent on destroying everything you are going to stay as low income economy.

No one want to be associated with you, no one want to invest in your country, no one want to operate in your country, if someone has Pakistani Visa stamp on passport you are not going to get US Visa anytime soon.

Then comes extravagant spending on military to keep India and Afghanistan engaged, ministers wasting millions on high profile lifestyle, cronies extracting their pound of flesh, how do you think they are going to survive? They have used all the leverage to stay afloat they don't really have many options. Perfect time for India to wreck havoc and see Pakistan collapse.
 
Time to eat grass is here.....

pkr.png
inr.png
 
Not that much but yeah it's a death sentence for industrial credit, demand and liquidity. Some major countries have survived even higher rates (Russia recently) but with already low investor sentiment, tightening global sanctions and blot of terrorism there is nothing that can help improve the situation.

It will help in curbing inflation though which is expected to go even higher but at the cost of death due to hunger, malnourishment at large scale. Man made famine.

Russia has a much bigger scale of economy and has resources of its own. You cannot compare that to Pakistan. It will be severely weakened.
 
There's a word for that: Ummah.

Of course, they don't understand that either.

There is a rise of anti-ummah types too....that are just straight up mercenary thinking too. Operate the whole country as to who bids the most for their fauj in span of say 5 year window.

Literally I'm getting pimped anyway (when ummah/identity used)....so start open bidding war (of course India not invited lol...at least officially.... that's the ultimate raison d'etre narrative that cannot be broached).

It is clear to me why they cannot build one civic institution on just about anything. Their really is warped sense of what a nation is.

No matter how much the ship gets battered and takes on water....who is steering it, or what the heading is (and how off-course it may be)....what matters is the ego trip of the crew apparently. I mean Ulysses did want to hear the Siren song too....BUT he told his crew to tie him to the mast and plug their ears. This is what is called basic intelligence over ego. It is opposite over there.
 
There is a rise of anti-ummah types too....that are just straight up mercenary thinking too. Operate the whole country as to who bids the most for their fauj in span of say 5 year window.

You are being very mild when you say "mercenary". "Female mercenaries" would be more apt, the kind that knock on car windows. Soldieresses of Fortune.

It is clear to me why they cannot build one civic institution on just about anything. Their really is warped sense of what a nation is.

Uniformed warlords do not build civic institutions.
 
Foreign Direct Investment in Pakistan drops by 52% in 10MFY19

LAHORE: The Foreign Direct Investment (FDI) in Pakistan plunged by 51.7 per cent to $1.376 billion during the first 10 months of current fiscal year, i.e. July to April, as compared to FDI of $2.849 billion reported in the corresponding period last year.

According to the latest data released by State Bank of Pakistan, the FDI for the month of April-19 amounted to $101.8 million, which is lower by 42.6 per cent as compared to $177.5 million reported in March 2019 and 55.2 per cent as compared to $227.5 million reported in April-18.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Gautam
Pakistan's economy on the brink of collapse

by Kamran Chaudhry
04/18/2019, 15.48

PAKISTAN : The government pledged to create ten million new jobs and build five million houses. With a 4 per cent growth rate, poverty will not be tackled, nor will per capita income increase by much. The government is negotiating a bailout with the International Monetary Fund. Terrorism is driving investors away.

1558497210097.png


Lahore (AsiaNews) – Pakistan’s economy has "reached the point of collapse. For the first time in four decades of research, I am deeply worried,” said Dr Kaiser Bengali, Dean of the Faculty of Management Science at the Shaheed Zulfikar Ali Bhutto Institute of Science and Technology, in Karachi.

The federal government is expected to present a new budget for the fiscal year 2019-20 on 24 May. However, “India might cause the collapse our economy as the US did with the USSR,” Bengali warns. “The alarm bells are ringing. We have no choice but to beg. I fear starvation, poverty and unemployment.”

Bengali, a former advisor for Planning and Development to the Chief Minister of Sindh province, spoke yesterday at a hotel in Lahore at the launching of his research titled State of the Economy 1990-2015; Economy on a Roller Coaster – And Stuck in the Mud!

The report, which evaluates Pakistan’s economy over a quarter of a century, examined three sectors: major crops, minor crops and large-scale manufacturing.

“Average GDP growth of 4 per cent cannot be expected to raise the per capita income sufficiently to reduce poverty,” the study states.

“Agriculture, the core of economy, has performed worse. Major crops sectors have grown at less than3 per cent and minor crops sector at less than 2 per cent. Large scale manufacturing has grown at just about 5 per cent.”

The picture is very serious, the economist told AsiaNews: “sales are declining, purchase power has ended. The most affected will be youth. An average family can no longer afford a house” and has “to share it with another.”

Last but not least, “publishing houses are shutting down. We cannot print even Quran in our country”.

Prime Minister Imran Khan and his government had promised ten million new jobs and five million new houses. Instead, Pakistan now faces a deepening economic crisis, a ballooning current account deficit and fast-depleting foreign reserves.

To deal with the situation, Islamabad is now finalising a bailout package with the International Monetary Fund (IMF) to stave off a balance of payments crisis, despite more than billion in short-term loans from allies such as China and Saudi Arabia.

According to Bengali, not only has the government made irresponsible claims about creating million jobs, it has “not given any direction in recent months. There is no indication from the state to consume domestic products.”

To complicate matters, the media have not talked about the economy and the threat of terrorism. “Extremist and sectarian organisations are another major blow to our economy. About 400 Shia doctors have been killed in only two years. Many industrialists have fled the country due to routine curfews. Foreign investors prefer holding meetings in Dubai and other countries.”

Pakistan's economy on the brink of collapse
 
Industry leaders shocked by rate hike, blame decision on ‘IMF pressure’

Aamir Shafaat Khan, Updated May 21, 2019

1558500048355.png


KARACHI: The business community on Monday reacted with dismay and some shock at the decision by the State Bank to raise the key policy discount rate by 1.5 per cent, bringing it to 12.25pc.

“I think there was no need for any further interest hike as food inflation was quite under control in April than March,” President Site Association of Industry, Saleem Parekh said.

“I am sure that the interest rate has been raised under the International Monetary Fund (IMF) pressure,” he said adding that the “business community has lost hope of rising factory output and exports. It now looks like a bad dream.”

He said the industries were already perturbed over rising cost of doing business and the latest hike in interest rate would further strangulate investment and hamper economic activities.

Mr Parekh said rupee devaluation against the dollar would not help boost exports as it has pushed up raw material prices thus putting additional burden on production cost making products in competitive in world market.


Commenting on the situation, Central Chairman Pakistan Hosiery Manufacturers and Exporters Association Jawed Bilwani questioned how the GDP will grow. “How will new industries come up and investors take risk of making investment in new ventures under the regime of soaring interest rates?” he questioned. He too opined that the increase in interest rate was as per IMF’s dictation.

President Federation of Pakistan Chambers of Commerce and Industry Daroo Khan Achakzai said the government is not running on its feet and currently is surrounded by a lot of problems.

While attributing interest rate surge to IMF’s pressure, he said it seems that the State Bank has taken a drastic step to take the interest rate at its peak and then it may either bring it down or maintain it in next policy statement after two months.

He said no steps have been taken so far to reduce cost of doing business. Mr Achakzai urged the government to hold a dialogue with the stakeholders for bringing down cost of doing business.

Chairman Pakistan Bedwear Exporters Association Shabir Ahmed said the State Bank has not taken a right decision as this will only stall industrialisation besides pushing up cost of production and hitting exports.

He said massive rupee devaluation has already cast a gloom as textile related industries would be unable to bring imported machinery due to rising cost of imports.

General Secretary Overseas Chambers of Commerce and Industry, M Abdul Aleem said the 1.5pc spike in the discount rate to 12.25pc is going to have negative impact on cost of doing business and will negatively impact on the growth of the economy and business.

We expect this action to negatively affect the disposable income and profitability of corporates. But in the longer run, we expect that economic adjustment measures will be taken, mainly in the upcoming budget to fill up the resource gap and manage this difficult time relatively better,” Mr Aleem said.

He said the rise in interest rate was not unexpected considering series of negative economic news like regular increase in inflation during the past ten months and before, record level of borrowings by the government from State Bank, sharp weakening of the rupee against the dollar, big shortfalls in revenue collection together with news of further increase in gas and utility prices and muted growth in agriculture and industrial sector were all indication of slower economic growth and difficult times ahead.

Bigger than expected

Most brokers and analysts thought that the hike exceeded expectations.

Veteran broker-turned-value investor at the market, Amin Tai said that in view of the current slowdown in the economy, such a steep increase in interest rates should not have been done when the rate of inflation is on its way down.

Stock broker and former chairman demutualisation committee, Shehzad Chamdia said the interest rate hike was “irrationally high”. And instead of narrowing the fiscal deficit through higher tax collection, an IMF bailout package was obtained and to cover inflation, interest rates have been pushed higher. “It’s a vicious circle for the economy” he said.

Topline Securities concurred, saying that the increase since Jan 2018 stands at 650bps and at 12.25pc it looms at almost eight years high.

In the previous Monetary Policy announced in March, the SBP had increased rates by 50bps.

The brokerage expects the rate hike to be negative for cement, steel and fertiliser sectors, while cash rich companies could benefit and certain banks would be major beneficiaries as higher interest rate would improve their Net Interest Margins.

Executive Director Next Capital Zulqarnain Khan observed that the increase was a sequel to SBP’s year-long effort to pre-empt the drop in savings and curb inflation. He thought that it would help stabilise dollar-rupee parity and could put a plug on capital flight.

He also believed that the cement and steel sectors which had led the market upside during the bull run of 2017, would now take the brunt of the blow and the impact could cascade to other sectors.

Published in Dawn, May 21st, 2019

Industry leaders shocked by rate hike, blame decision on ‘IMF pressure’ - Pakistan - DAWN.COM
 
Fiscal blowout as deficit jumps to 5pc, revenues flat

Khaleeq Kiani, May 22, 2019

1558500296412.png


ISLAMABAD: In the Pakistan Tehreek-i-Insaf’s first year in office, the country’s fiscal deficit in first three quarters (July-March) of the current fiscal year peaked to five per cent of GDP as expenditures broke past records and revenue performance was the lowest almost in a decade.

The details of fiscal operations released by the ministry of finance on Tuesday put the country’s nine-month total fiscal deficit at Rs1.922 trillion — the highest 3rd quarter deficit recorded in a decade, which is the time period for which data is maintained on the ministry’s website. It was Rs1.48tr in the same period last year.

All major fiscal indicators — both on expenditure and revenue side — showed a marked deterioration across the board. There appeared to be no control on runaway expenditures as revenue collection turned flat. The dismal outturn in the data will put more pressure on the government to show a strengthened revenue mobilisation effort, as well as a stronger will to contain expenditures in the budget that is expected to be announced in early June.

Defence and debt servicing remain fastest growing expenditure items

The data shows a sharp spike in the deficit in the third quarter, which runs from January to March 2019, of about Rs900bn or 2.3pc of GDP. The figure is only slightly smaller than the deficit of the first two quarters, running from July to December 2018, combined. For the first two quarters, the total deficit was Rs1.02tr or 2.7pc of GDP. The deficit jumped despite a steep fall of 34pc in development spending in the first nine months of the fiscal year.

The highest full year fiscal deficit since 2000 was recorded at 8pc in fiscal year 2012-13 and even that year, nine-month gap between revenue and expenditure had amounted to 4.4pc of GDP, according to the ministry of finance data.

Mark-up payments in first nine months this year were reported at 3.8pc of GDP — the highest since 2009 — compared to 3.4pc in the same period last year. In absolute terms, an amount of Rs1.459tr was spent on mark-up payments this year compared to significantly lower debt servicing of Rs1.172tr last year. Interest rates nearly doubled in this period and the rupee has seen a sharp devaluation as well. Both developments would raise mark-up costs for the government, in addition to fresh borrowing.

Defence spending picked up pace sharply in the third quarter, coming in at 2pc of GDP in nine months, when there is no precedent for defence spending going beyond 1.9pc of GDP even for the full year, in the past 11 years. For the full period running from July to March, defence spending rose by 24.1pc from last year, coming in at Rs774.8bn compared to Rs623.8bn in the same period last year.

Revenues have flattened out between July and March, presenting the government with its most serious challenge. Collections till March of 2019 came in at Rs3.583tr compared to Rs3.582tr in the same period last year. But it actually fell significantly to 9.3pc of GDP this year compared to 10.4pc of same period last year.

This meant that the government’s tax machinery showed negative performance both in terms of absolute numbers and as percentage of GDP, clear manifestation of about Rs350bn revenue shortfall. Under the IMF programme the government is hoping to accede to before the start of next fiscal year, raising revenues will be a big challenge.

Non-tax revenues in nine months of this year amounted to Rs421.6bn, significantly lower than last year’s Rs506bn. As such, the non-tax revenue amounted to 1.1pc of GDP compared to 1.5pc of GDP last year. Non-tax revenue to GDP ratio was the lowest since 2008-09.

Current expenditure on the other hand amounted to 12.5pc of GDP in nine months that was the highest since 2008-09. Last year current expenditure was reported at 11.8pc of GDP that was also the highest in a decade. In absolute numbers, the current expenditure amounted to Rs4.798 trillion compared to Rs4.075 trillion last year.

Development expenditure and net lending amounted to 1.8pc of GDP – the lowest since 2008-09. Last year, development expenditure and net lending had stood at 2.9pc of GDP. The data showed about Rs684bn spending on this count in first nine months of current year, about 32pc lower than last year’s Rs1.002 trillion.

Total expenditure on the other hand increased to 14.3pc of GDP in first nine months of current fiscal year. Other than last year’s total expenditure of 14.7pc of GDP in nine months, the nine month total expenditure has never gone beyond 14pc of GDP since 2008-09 for which data is available.

Total development expenditure in first nine months amounted to Rs656bn this year compared to Rs993bn of comparable period last year, down by 34pc.

Published in Dawn, May 22nd, 2019

Fiscal blowout as deficit jumps to 5pc, revenues flat - Newspaper - DAWN.COM
 
  • Like
Reactions: BlackOpsIndia
Imports shrink, exports stagnate, FDI plummets: Current account deficit drops 27pc

Fayaz Hussain, Updated May 22, 2019

1558524619888.png


KARACHI: The country’s current account deficit (CAD) contracted by 27 per cent to $11.586 billion during the first 10 months of the current fiscal year compared to $15.864bn during the same period last fiscal year, according to latest data released by the State Bank of Pakistan.

The contraction is mainly due to 5pc decrease in total imports even as exports have dropped by around 2pc despite devaluation of the local currency and incentives announced by the government. In addition to that, $1.4bn increase in workers’ remittances also helped prop up overall foreign exchange reserves.

The CAD in April declined to $1.24bn, down 45.4pc from $2.275bn in April 2018.

The government has faced challenges to arrest the widening current account deficit despite bilateral borrowings from Saudi Arabia, UAE and China. However, the funds have proven inadequate to finance the CAD as the country’s reserves have declined to $8.8bn — enough for less than three months of import cover due to external debt servicing according to the State Bank.

The rapid decline in reserves forced the government to approach the International Monetary Fund. The fund, after long negotiations, agreed to a 39-month Extended Fund Facility for about $6bn to restore macroeconomic stability and support sustainable economic growth and ensure additional external financing. However, the agreement comes with strings attached including, some say, commitments to roll over bilateral loans, interest rate hike, further devaluation of the currency, and hikes in utility prices including gas and electricity in the upcoming budget.

The agreement with the IMF is likely to be followed by inflows from other lending agencies including the World Bank and the Asian Development Bank.

The CAD, during the last fiscal year, hit record high of $18.619bn depleting reserves at roughly $1.5bn per month stressing government’s ability to payback liabilities.

However, the government’s efforts to compress imports in the ongoing fiscal year are finally bearing fruit as the total imports dipped to $44.033bn, down 7.87pc against the same period last year.

The government introduced corrective measures such as the imposition of regulatory duties and banning furnace oil imports. Furthermore, after introducing new rules governing imports of used vehicles pushing the import bill has downwards during the period under review.

The challenge for the government lies in reversing the declining trend in exports, which have declined 2pc to $20.099bn despite massive devaluation of 18pc in the rupee’s value during the last 10 months and special incentives for export-oriented sectors including textile..

The government had earlier claimed the impact of currency devaluation will be visible in the exports, anticipating a pickup in foreign sales and a steep decline in imports in the months ahead, however, exports have seen no significant improvement.

Foreign investment halves to $1.4bn

As the government embarks on an arduous journey to fix the economic imbalances with the help of International Monetary Fund (IMF) bailout, the foreign direct investment (FDI) halved to $1.376 billion during the first 10 months of this fiscal year from $2.489bn in the corresponding period last year.

The FDI inflows fell to $101.8 million in April, down 42.6 per cent compared to $177.5m in March and plunged by 55.2pc year-on-year compared to $227.5m in April 2018.

Inflows from China, leading investor in the country, declined by 72 per cent to $429m during the July-April period compared to $1.731bn in the same period last fiscal year as major infrastructure-related projects under the China-Pakistan Economic Corridor near completion.

However, the United Kingdom and the United States with $156m and $76m respectively also shied away from investing in the country amid record fall in the rupee’s value and economic slowdown.

On the other hand, investment from Netherlands dropped to $67.5m during the period under review from $86.5m in the same period last year.

Sector-wise, construction led the chart attracting $386.8m during the July-April period of 2018-19 followed by oil and gas exploration, financial business, and electrical machinery with $287.3m, $256.6m, and $287.3m respectively.

Power sector, however, witnessed an outflow of $281m during the first 10 months against $1bn FDI in the same period last year followed by net outflow of $144m in the communication sector.

On a monthly basis, inflows in the financial business and power sector led with $22.1m and $19.8m respectively.

The falling FDI is a troublesome for the government as the inflows from foreign countries help prop up the country’s current account balance which has worsened amid declining exports.

The government, in order to avoid a balance of payments crisis, approached IMF to secure a bailout programme. Moreover, portfolio investment outflow was $990.6m during the period under review compared to inflow of $2.45bn during the same period last year.

Published in Dawn, May 22nd, 2019

Imports shrink, exports stagnate, FDI plummets: Current account deficit drops 27pc - Newspaper - DAWN.COM
 
Pakistan's economy on the brink of collapse

by Kamran Chaudhry
04/18/2019, 15.48

PAKISTAN : The government pledged to create ten million new jobs and build five million houses. With a 4 per cent growth rate, poverty will not be tackled, nor will per capita income increase by much. The government is negotiating a bailout with the International Monetary Fund. Terrorism is driving investors away.

View attachment 6775

Lahore (AsiaNews) – Pakistan’s economy has "reached the point of collapse. For the first time in four decades of research, I am deeply worried,” said Dr Kaiser Bengali, Dean of the Faculty of Management Science at the Shaheed Zulfikar Ali Bhutto Institute of Science and Technology, in Karachi.

The federal government is expected to present a new budget for the fiscal year 2019-20 on 24 May. However, “India might cause the collapse our economy as the US did with the USSR,” Bengali warns. “The alarm bells are ringing. We have no choice but to beg. I fear starvation, poverty and unemployment.”

Bengali, a former advisor for Planning and Development to the Chief Minister of Sindh province, spoke yesterday at a hotel in Lahore at the launching of his research titled State of the Economy 1990-2015; Economy on a Roller Coaster – And Stuck in the Mud!

The report, which evaluates Pakistan’s economy over a quarter of a century, examined three sectors: major crops, minor crops and large-scale manufacturing.

“Average GDP growth of 4 per cent cannot be expected to raise the per capita income sufficiently to reduce poverty,” the study states.

“Agriculture, the core of economy, has performed worse. Major crops sectors have grown at less than3 per cent and minor crops sector at less than 2 per cent. Large scale manufacturing has grown at just about 5 per cent.”

The picture is very serious, the economist told AsiaNews: “sales are declining, purchase power has ended. The most affected will be youth. An average family can no longer afford a house” and has “to share it with another.”

Last but not least, “publishing houses are shutting down. We cannot print even Quran in our country”.

Prime Minister Imran Khan and his government had promised ten million new jobs and five million new houses. Instead, Pakistan now faces a deepening economic crisis, a ballooning current account deficit and fast-depleting foreign reserves.

To deal with the situation, Islamabad is now finalising a bailout package with the International Monetary Fund (IMF) to stave off a balance of payments crisis, despite more than billion in short-term loans from allies such as China and Saudi Arabia.

According to Bengali, not only has the government made irresponsible claims about creating million jobs, it has “not given any direction in recent months. There is no indication from the state to consume domestic products.”

To complicate matters, the media have not talked about the economy and the threat of terrorism. “Extremist and sectarian organisations are another major blow to our economy. About 400 Shia doctors have been killed in only two years. Many industrialists have fled the country due to routine curfews. Foreign investors prefer holding meetings in Dubai and other countries.”

Pakistan's economy on the brink of collapse

Pretty ironic that the warning is coming from a "Bengali".
 
Anyone notice the other side of the equation? Pakistan does not have two pennies to rub together, but the Army is buying new gear and also making emergency off the shelf purchases?

Does any one feel its a bit strange?
 
Anyone notice the other side of the equation? Pakistan does not have two pennies to rub together, but the Army is buying new gear and also making emergency off the shelf purchases?

Does any one feel its a bit strange?
We should know about the revenue of the fauji foundation to understand that, they have every kind of industry from food to cement and all.