Exactly, the onus is on us & there has been no official proof provided so far. That was the point of my post.
Unless that happens, it is not a loss of face for the Chinese establishment.
Line of Actual Control (LAC) : India & Tibet Border Updates
- Thread starter Shashank
- Start date
Exactly, the onus is on us & there has been no official proof provided so far. That was the point of my post.
Unless that happens, it is not a loss of face for the Chinese establishment.
can some one kick that idiot out from there. we dont need to show them live what all systems are being present across the border.
Truth is Shukla was right. He said some truths and bhakats called him khangrassi, traitor, bla bla bla just because they don't want to admit our failures and continue to live in denial. To be fair, I was also hoping that he is wrong. Shukla said multiple army officers are captured and it looks like it is true.
This is not the first time Shukla spoke something army refused to confirm and turned out to be true. He was the first one to report that IAF helicopter shot down on 27th Feb was shot down by Indian military itself,something IAF was not confirming. Bhakats called him a lier & Khangrassi for the next one month untill military confirmed court marshal.
Last edited:
Out of 45, 25 released that day, 10 yesterday remaining 10, are they still in Chinese custody?
The statement of nobody captive anymore is still from "sources" and not official.
What leverage a poor family have when they pay abductors to get their loved ones back?
For once can you speak without delusions of something grand happening in favor of India which can not be told to world?
Lack of overt response or No Response? I think we must start calling out both political and armed institution equally now.
Every aircraft was accounted for on Feb 27 until Abhinandan was paraded with a a broken nose.
We always do "something" which can not be told and can not be seen and can not be verified.
Scoundrels making a fool of nation for 70 years.
And why not even a peep about the PLA soldiers who were in our custody ? The story about 10 Indian captives is circulating every where..
Captivity is becoming a regular pass time for our soldiers. First in May at Pangong, then now in June at Galwan, looks like IA / ITBP have a monthly quota of captured soldiers to fill.
I mean ppl are
And as for politics is concerned why would Modi or the BJP take political responsibility for the sheer incompetence of IAF.
OTOH what would have happened if govt accepted that 10 soldiers are in custody, it would have increased public pressure and given China more leverage in negotiations. Shukla was just a Colonel, I am pretty sure all other retd. higher-ranking officials like Maj Gens, Lt Gens definitely knew more, there is a reason they keep shut. I remember Shyam Sharan, Shiv Shankar Menon saying something on the same line a few days back!
The time to pin blame is not now, you can do it whenever this thing gets over, you have ample time for that. Divulging information in an ongoing operation/ standoff is not being truthfulness, its irresponsible behaviour akin to the fifth column!
Every Tom, Dick and Harry everywhere and in this forum knew it was shot down by IAF in friendly fire, what was so path-breaking in what Shukla told?
And as for politics is concerned why would Modi or the BJP take political responsibility for the sheer incompetence of IAF.
OTOH what would have happened if govt accepted that 10 soldiers are in custody, it would have increased public pressure and given China more leverage in negotiations. Shukla was just a Colonel, I am pretty sure all other retd. higher-ranking officials like Maj Gens, Lt Gens definitely knew more, there is a reason they keep shut. I remember Shyam Sharan, Shiv Shankar Menon saying something on the same line a few days back!
The time to pin blame is not now, you can do it whenever this thing gets over, you have ample time for that. Divulging information in an ongoing operation/ standoff is not being truthfulness, its irresponsible behaviour akin to the fifth column!
Must have some video for all this act by Chinese while our men were counting their stretchers. Or even that is confidential or memory card got corrupted?
Just the enemy cordons off that area for 41 days and then take journalists on a highly restricted and guarded tour.
Offcourse, we are unhappy with them, we wont "talk" to them especially our tough "leaders".
May be we have outsourced talking now to army and fighting to internet warriors.
Well did the Chinese memory cards also get corrupted that they aren't releasing videos/pics either? The aim is to diffuse the situation in our favour with as less effort possible and not to give you social media cred to brag about.
Simple because BJP and its army has people on their pay roll to spread all kind of misinformation and we as a civilians must believe them out of patriotism.
99% Indians are already cheering 43 chinese deaths.
Why they need to release videos when they can embarrass us by releasing captives (walking proofs)?
Any videos for that? Like how do I believe that they actually released some?
If we really had chinese soldiers in custody, forget army statement, just a tweet from ANI or some of BJPs trusted journalists would have been enough, until China explicitly denied it.. But, we have complete radio silence. It only means that there were no chinese hostages..
Nothing has happened, no captives, no deaths, no killing. Please sleep tight.