IAF Chronicles - A side view of whats going on behind the closed doors in New Delhi

Status
Not open for further replies.
I will speak of general defence sabotage:
- Tejas in 2014 had only airframe and FBW, nothing else. The same condition was also seen in 2008-9. Why wasn't Tejas flown heavily and tested rigorously to gain feedback etc, even with imported engine. But, India deliberately chose not to.
- Test bed was denied to Kaveri and India had to regularly fly to Russia. The most important aspect of engine development is test bed to regularly check and fine tune.
- The head of Kaveri development was arrested on 2011 on a flimsy charge which appeared more or less targeted.
- Several projects like Scorpene, IAC-1 which was flagged off in NDA-1 time was delayed incessantly.
- Ammunitions were imported, Tatra trucks were imported despite easy availability from Indian alternative.
- No orders were placed between 2012-2014 as stated by Parrikar.
- Arjun Tank sabotaged by changing GSQR.

So on...

PS: You were never nice. No need of such remarks
Stop the BS and prove GoI's Sabotage of Kaveri Engine.
 
It would be a mistake to think Modi is making a blunder. Modi is not making any blunder. Everything is moving as per the plan.



Modi does not need to explain anything. Both IAF & BJP are anti-Russia. The only difference between them is IAF prefers French ones over US ones. Neither the IAF nor BJP are interested in Indian or Russian equipment. IAF would any day pick F-16s over LCA. I expect IAF to strongly come out and defend the decision on F-16s quoting falling numbers should Congress try to politicise the deal like they did in case of RAFALEs. The recently released RFP for Teja MK1A would act their defence too as IAF would claim they have shown the intent for Indian products but HAL could not deliver and hence the need.

The reality is, IAF doesn't have any other option other than going for a foreign SEF if it wants to meet the target of 42-45 sqn by 2035>

IAF is really looking forward to the Mk-2 and would prefer it over the F-16, believe me. I've spoken to someone very high up in the chain personally. But the problem is that the govt is pushing them to select the F-16 as the new SEF to satisfy its foreign policy goals, even while it hasn't cleared the technical trials.
IAF is using this to their advantage by pressuring GoI to order more Rafales ASAP while LM find a way to modify the jets to clear the trials so that tht acquisition can move forward.
 
Last edited:
  • Like
Reactions: Sathya and Aashish
Deputy Russian PM Dmitry Rogozin calls on PM Narendra Modi

Deputy Russian PM Dmitry Rogozin calls on PM Narendra Modi | Latest News & Updates at Daily News & Analysis
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Nirmala Sitharaman holds talks with Russian deputy PM to boost defence ties

Nirmala Sitharaman and Russian deputy PM Dmitry Rogozin hold wide-ranging talks with a focus on further boosting the bilateral defence and security ties

Nirmala Sitharaman holds talks with Russian deputy PM to boost defence ties

I expect the never ending talks with Russia with no substantial results to continue until Modi/BJP is out of power. I expect them to sign a dozen MOUs too.:D
 
Last edited:
  • Like
Reactions: Aashish
I expect the never ending talks with Russia with no substantial results would continue until Modi/BJP is out of power. I expect them to sign a dozen MOUs too.:D

See the Photo of Modi and Rogozin

How happy he i.e. Rogozin looks

1514053664875.png
 

Attachments

  • 1514053784678.png
    1514053784678.png
    1.2 MB · Views: 194
Stop the BS and prove GoI's Sabotage of Kaveri Engine.
Not providing test bed, arresting of chief of Keveri engine in 2011 is sabotage.
The reality is, IAF doesn't have any other option other than going for a foreign SEF if it wants to meet the target of 42-45 sqn by 2035>

IAF is really looking forward to the Mk-2 and would prefer it over the F-16, believe me. I've spoken to someone very high up in the chain personally. But the problem is govt is pushing them to select the F-16 as the new SEF to satisfy its foreign policy goals, even while it hasn't cleared the technical trials.
IAF is using this to their advantage by pressuring GoI to order more Rafales ASAP while LM find a way to modify the jets to clear the trials so that tht acquisition can move forward.
Let us not come to this conclusion till the deal is made. Using terms like "political goals" is really vague. Discussing about whether it will be bought or not is like playing prediction game. You an utmost give rationale to the best choice available, not predict these decisions
 
- MOD is asking whom for a way out ? i thought this is their decision to make

Modi is like a Banyan Tree which will not allow no other tree to grow under it.

Modi leadership style is authoritarian. You should know how Modi destroyed the likes of Advani, Keshubhai, Tagodia and even Bhagwat. There is a reason why MP was shown the door. Modi likes yes masters and CCS has four of them. The only one who calls shots in CCS is PMO i.e. Modi himself.

-
lastly Rafale deal is helping us many other programs in offsets
is there any mention of any thing like that in F16 deal..

There would be zero ToT. This has been made very clear and is part of the draft agreement that was agreed upon in principle earlier this year.
 
Yes, he had character weakness but that was irrelevant to Kaveri project. Even the arrest appeared to be targeted with someone giving the exact time and place of him to get him arrested.

If Kaveri is stuck it is Not because of This Gentleman visiting massage parlours

It is because the huge Knowledge and Technological GAP that we have to bridge

That is where the French Help is welcome

By the way all your allegations are absurd ; false and Motivated
 
The reality is, IAF doesn't have any other option other than going for a foreign SEF if it wants to meet the target of 42-45 sqn by 2035>

IAF is really looking forward to the Mk-2 and would prefer it over the F-16, believe me. I've spoken to someone very high up in the chain personally. But the problem is govt is pushing them to select the F-16 as the new SEF to satisfy its foreign policy goals, even while it hasn't cleared the technical trials.
IAF is using this to their advantage by pressuring GoI to order more Rafales ASAP while LM find a way to modify the jets to clear the trials so that tht acquisition can move forward.

The F16 purchase is more of an attempt to normalize the indo-us trade deficit of 24Bn also as the USA is India's no1 trading partner with 42Bn we have our mutual interest. if India is not going for F16 purchase we will go for some other hi-tech military purchase but that deal should benefit India with similar kind of clause like offshore manufacturing facilities.
 
If Kaveri is stuck it is Not because of This Gentleman visiting massage parlours

It is because the huge Knowledge and Technological GAP that we have to bridge

That is where the French Help is welcome

By the way all your allegations are absurd ; false and Motivated

As I said, delays are something that can be attributed to everything. But, considering the fact that other countries did it much quickly shows that there wasn't good leadership or political motivation. Lack of test facility is a real reason.
 
In all this the biggest take away for me the the support Iaf is showing for the LCA. This is contrary to the perception created in the recent past about Iaf treating the lca like a step child. A combination of Rafale Su30 and LCA will give IAF all the range and fighting flexibility it needs in the foreseeable future and give a great cushion in terms of timelines for FGFA development and induction. Throw in the M2k, jaguar and the mig 29 numbers in the middle x and we are looking at a very potent air arm.

The f16 just doesn't seem to fit into this mix and certainly not at 145M a pop

What people need to understand is neither PMO nor IAF has any love for the LCA.

LCA is just a pawn in the negotiations between PMO and IAF.

If PMO pushes too strongly on F-16s, IAF starts supporting LCA and
If IAF pushes too strongly on RAFALEs, PMO starts pushing LCA.
That's pretty much the utility of the LCA.

IAF is just negotiating hard to get as many follow-on RAFALEs as possible in lieu of they agreeing to PMOs proposal to procure F-16s. That's about it.
 
The F16 purchase is more of an attempt to normalize the indo-us trade deficit of 24Bn also as the USA is India's no1 trading partner with 42Bn we have our mutual interest. if India is not going for F16 purchase we will go for some other hi-tech military purchase but that deal should benefit India with similar kind of clause like offshore manufacturing facilities.

But not with Trump's policy. If trade deficit was the only issue, we can always buy more Chinooks, Apaches, Poseidons, UAVs and the NMRH contract. But that's not what the US wants. They want inroads to our military planning and policies.
I mean, what kind of an security partner would India be to them if we don't share combat assets?? And Apaches don't count.
 
Not providing test bed, arresting of chief of Keveri engine in 2011 is sabotage.

Wow. Did GTRE ask for a AT and FTB? Show me one document where GTRE or ADA's proposal for a test bed was rejected by GoI?
ground testing was extensively carried out for Kaveri AT and FTB conducted in CIAM russia was close to a combined 150 hrs whereas if I recall correctly ground testing clocked more than 2600 hrs. Ground testing constitutes a volume of 17 times more that that for AT and FTB

What was the chief of kaveri engine arrested on? Wasn't Kaveri supposed be ready by 1998 how does what happened in 2011 can explain missing the project deadline of 1998 to all the extensions it got till it was de-linked in 2008 , is there some time travel conspiracy here now. The first prototype for LCA was supposed fly using one of the 8 engine prototypes to complete by 98. Even in 2005 DRDO was claiming that by 2007 LCA prototype should be flying with Kaveri Engine, and that was decade ago.

The Hindu : National : Good progress on Kaveri engine, says DRDO chief
 
Last edited:
IAF is really looking forward to the Mk-2 and would prefer it over the F-16, believe me. I've spoken to someone very high up in the chain personally.

Incorrect. LCA has always been an excuse and punching bag for both PMO & IAF.

But the problem is that the govt is pushing them to select the F-16 as the new SEF to satisfy its foreign policy goals, even while it hasn't cleared the technical trials.
IAF is using this to their advantage by pressuring GoI to order more Rafales ASAP

Fully agree here.

while LM find a way to modify the jets to clear the trials so that tht acquisition can move forward.

Take it from me. There will be no F-16s trials like MMRCA. We are only talking about IAF putting the stamp of approval and that would happen as soon as additional RAFALE numbers have been agreed upon between PMO & IAF.
 
Wow. Did GTRE ask for a AT and FTB? Show me one document where GTRE or ADA's proposal for a test bed was rejected by GoI?
ground testing was extensively carried out for Kaveri AT and FTB conducted in CIAM russia was close to a combined 150 hrs whereas if I recall correctly ground testing clocked more than 2600 hrs. Ground testing constitutes a volume of 17 times more that that for AT and FTB

What was the chief of kaveri engine arrested on? Wasn't Kaveri supposed be ready by 1998 how does what happened in 2011 can explain missing the project deadline of 1998 to all the extensions it got till it was de-linked in 2008 , is there some time travel conspiracy here now. The first prototype for LCA was supposed fly using one of the 8 engine protyes to compete by 98. Even in 2005 DRDO was claiming that by 2007 LCA prototype should be flying with Kaveri Engine, and that was decade ago.

The Hindu : National : Good progress on Kaveri engine, says DRDO chief

Who ruled from 1990-1998? Congress, Gujral etc. Good luck with it.
 
Incorrect. LCA has always been an excuse and punching bag for both PMO & IAF.



Fully agree here.



Take it from me. There will be no F-16s trials like MMRCA. We are only talking about IAF putting the stamp of approval and that would happen as soon as additional RAFALE numbers have been agreed upon between PMO & IAF.

F 16 will happen Only when Modi comes back again in 2019

There are Too many things that are Left to be discussed and decided such as
The Two Remaining Foundation agreements ; TOT ; Price ; Life cycle costs
Customisations ; spares etc ; etc

We have just One year Left Before which the Govt goes into Election mode

And secondly Money is a Big factor here

There are too many competing needs and priorities
 
F 16 will happen Only when Modi comes back again in 2019

There are Too many things that are Left to be discussed and decided such as
The Two Remaining Foundation agreements ; TOT ; Price ; Life cycle costs
Customisations ; spares etc ; etc

We have just One year Left Before which the Govt goes into Election mode

And secondly Money is a Big factor here

There are too many competing needs and priorities

The pint here is that there is no need for F16 at all. It serves no purpose. Wartime needs are:
1) Manufacturing large quantity
2) Spare part availability at will instantly
3) Repairing ability

No war can be won with few hundred aircraft, or without spare parts at right time or without ability to do maintenance and repairs.

All this needs large Indigenous manufacturing
 
But not with Trump's policy. If trade deficit was the only issue, we can always buy more Chinooks, Apaches, Poseidons, UAVs and the NMRH contract. But that's not what the US wants. They want inroads to our military planning and policies.
I mean, what kind of an security partner would India be to them if we don't share combat assets?? And Apaches don't count.
Everyone has their own priorities we have our own also defence manufacturer lobby is not new to IAF or MOD. As I said earlier purchase should be with clause of offshore development facility (Employment ) and hope we have the best brain to take the decision so let's wait and watch.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Nick
Status
Not open for further replies.