Sukhoi Su-30MKI

Read again in entirety>" obsolescence refers to being outdated , no longer in use, not needed in service" not just being outdated as you conveniently cherry pick.
Sorry to intervene in this discussion but normaly obsolescence refers to being no more able to interact with its technical environment witch is perhaps not the case here ?
 
And Rafales are not mission specific, it will conjure Hammers, Exocets and Meteors out of thin air onto its hard points ? Every load out is mission specific. If you load out rafales wit two Matra Magics ad rest Hammers, it wont be swinging into hunting F16's in BVR at 100km magically.

A typical strike load comes with BVR/WVR missiles.

With aircraft like MKI, Jaguars, Mig-29, LCA, M-2000 etc, you need as many as 12 aircraft to perform a mission that you need only 4 Rafales for because of the Rafale's ability to switch roles in the middle of flight. Rafale does not need recce, fighter sweep, escort etc.
 
  • Agree
Reactions: Bon Plan
The Jaguar is one of our most important aircraft around, that's why it has the nuclear missions as well.

Jaguars were phased out in other air forces due to compulsion, not choice. But if we are to replace it, we will need the Rafale, not the MKI.
I call BS about this Nuclear delivery. I have had conversation with a lot of guys from HAL, and It does not take anything special for nuclear delivery. We can drop a live nuke from IL 76 is needed, do not get swept in this nomenclature. There is very little that is needed to arm the payload which can be done within 30 mins if needed.

Jaguar is god awful system that India bought because it couldn't get the viggen which it really wanted. The only good thing about the Jag is it's amazingly engineered undercarriage unit. When it comes to aerodynamic performance its a *censored*ing pig. Once loaded a mig25 with the turning radius the size of texas can bring it down. Plus it is an extremely slow moving aircraft when loaded. You really need to talk to some Pilots, you would come to the realization why jags are the butt of most jokes in the IAF.
 
With the J-20 in operation service, even the incomplete one will dominate the MKI.
we do not know this yet. Its one thing to not underestimate the enemy - its another to over estimate based on facts only provided by the chinese.

No third country or third party have ever verified the claims of the Chinese. please understand, the chinese may have great strength in manufacturing in huge numbers and quickly, but their radars, engines, stealth tech is still untested and unknown.
 
Sorry to intervene in this discussion but normaly obsolescence refers to being no more able to interact with its technical environment witch is perhaps not the case here ?

Yes. Not now, but it will be in less than 5 years. Once the J-20s start coming in in large numbers.
 
  • Agree
Reactions: Herciv
A typical strike load comes with BVR/WVR missiles.

With aircraft like MKI, Jaguars, Mig-29, LCA, M-2000 etc, you need as many as 12 aircraft to perform a mission that you need only 4 Rafales for because of the Rafale's ability to switch roles in the middle of flight. Rafale does not need recce, fighter sweep, escort etc.
OMG where the hell do you get these BS from. We have configured 6 Aircraft strike packages in 2006, who is selling you this stuff.
 
Next wonder why the french and english decommissioned its Jaguars if it was indeed that relevant? Even oman and Ecuador retired theirs.
France and the UK were building new aircraft to replace them. The Mirage 2000D and the Rafale replaced the Jaguar in French service while the Tornado and the Typhoon replaced it in British service.

Ecuador is a poor country. The Jaguars weren't replaced; the squadron that flew them was simply dissolved. They're still operating the Cheetah and Kfir, two bootleg variants of the Mirage III, so it's not like they've replaced their Jaguars with more modern aircraft.

Oman on the other hand was rich enough to replace them with Typhoons and F-16.

India is in a different situation: unlike France and the UK, it had no indigenous replacement ready to replace the Jaguars, unlike Oman it was too poor to purchase replacements from abroad, and unlike Ecuador it still had enough money to upgrade them and keep operating them.

It has always been a POS aircraft

Them's fighting words. The Jaguar was a very good aircraft in the 1970s and 1980s.
 
I call BS about this Nuclear delivery. I have had conversation with a lot of guys from HAL, and It does not take anything special for nuclear delivery. We can drop a live nuke from IL 76 is needed, do not get swept in this nomenclature. There is very little that is needed to arm the payload which can be done within 30 mins if needed.

Incorrect. The Jaguar has the hardening necessary to drop nukes, other aircraft can't do it.

Jaguar is god awful system that India bought because it couldn't get the viggen which it really wanted. The only good thing about the Jag is it's amazingly engineered undercarriage unit. When it comes to aerodynamic performance its a *censored*ing pig. Once loaded a mig25 with the turning radius the size of texas can bring it down. Plus it is an extremely slow moving aircraft when loaded. You really need to talk to some Pilots, you would come to the realization why jags are the butt of most jokes in the IAF.

Well, that's why the new engine.

No, the IAF wasn't interested in the Viggen.
Quarter Century of the Jaguar in India - Bharat Rakshak:Indian Air Force
 
OMG where the hell do you get these BS from. We have configured 6 Aircraft strike packages in 2006, who is selling you this stuff.

A 6 aircraft strike package will still require recce and top cover. And of course a hit on payload.

The example I gave will have 4 Jaguars carrying 8 500Kg bombs. 2 Rafales are enough for that. If you want a 6 aircraft package, the payload should comfortably decrease by half.
 
Incorrect. The Jaguar has the hardening necessary to drop nukes, other aircraft can't do it.
Please tell me the flexural rigidity needed for a hardpoint, especially the one that can carry a KAB1500L (1500KG=3300lb ) but cannot qualify for a air delivered nuke.
Specially when Jag is known for the 1000lb AN52 Nuke.
 
the chinese govt sources themselves are very unreliable, and you are basing all the dooms day scenario on forum messages and fan boy stuff?

A lot of the stuff that has been coming out on forums are deliberately leaked by the CCP because they don't have official channels of revealing such stuff.