Air Battle over Kashmir : MiG-21 Bison shoots down F-16

We should be Very Thankful to Pakistan
For Feb 26 and 27

Otherwise there would have been no changes and improvements

And In the present stand off with China
We would have been caught totally unawares and blindsided
It was a blessing in disguise. Gave us a reality check in some sense. Even the information warfare has improved post 27th Feb...
 
He's basically saying that the engagement took place at Dmax at a particular altitude.

This is the problem @vstol Jockey with long range shots. Although it won't kill, a long range shot even at Dmax will force the defender to go cold. This will allow a stealth strike package to slip in an attack of their own. Hence the need to be able to match or exceed the Dmax of the enemy missile to force them also to go cold along with you.

The AMRAAM C5's Dmax is probably only 40-45% of the Meteor's. It's a shame that we did not have the Meteor or Derby ER at the time.
Absolutely true. Its beyond my understanding that if a noob can understand the advantage of making enemy jet defensive by launching solves(or at least 1) BVRAAM at Dmax simply by watching numerous engagements senerio on DCS, how can a professional pilot and a frofessional airforce worth of its salt could miss that.
Are our boys inferior to those DCS playing computer jockeys ? I mean just look at a YouTube by the name Growling sidewinder and the knowledge he has gained regarding WVR and BVR dogfights (mostly one on one) .
Don’t we have such culture among our boys? Are the flying jets just to fulfill their duty and earn salary ?

Most definitely. This govt's been working overtime ever since the weaknesses became public. I'd actually say the IAF woke up to their deficiencies and are making up with emergency purchases.

We are still not there yet, but we are getting where we need to be really quickly.

The RVV-SD and Astra Mk1 povide a certain amount of parity (not superiority), but what's more important is the supply of SAMs from Israeli stores. Since most of the action we see appears to be local, at least our troops will operate under the protection of capable SAMs. I hope Depsang's under the protection of some Israeli SAMs. The Chinese may concentrate there with their perceived armour superiority and the region's proximity to suitable PLAAF air bases, especially when they likely have significant disadvantages everywhere else.

Better late than never.
So its true that IAF hides its weakness till its *censored* is being whooped by PAF and then go for a routine ‘emergency buying spree’ to cope up with the humiliation and then after sit on their asses to repeat the cycle.

What the US is doing is not a good thing for them. It's the exact opposite of what they should actually be doing since an insurgency trains you for something else entirely. In Iraq and Afghanistan, they should have done what the IA did in Kashmir, that is withdraw the regular forces and create a counterinsurgency force like the RR. The last time they fought a proper air war was back during Vietnam.

Kargil was indeed a wake up call, and we did modernise right after that. All the big ticket deals were signed during that time. Procurement of MKI, Vikramaditya, Phalcon etc, along with LCA, Dhruv, SSBN, BMD, Pinaka R&D, and so on. But the minute UPA came to power, military modernisation was pushed to the side for 10 years, until NDA came back to power again.
There are a lot of wake up calls in our history like 47 war and loosing 2/3 kashmir, 65 war and loosing 1/3 airforce on day 1of war, 72 and loosing opportunity to gain anything significant or even forcing defeated enemy to release our POWs , Kargil blunder and loosing men just because some one didn’t do his job .
This last year wake up call is a routine Morning Alarm to IAF and India.
 
Last edited:
  • Like
Reactions: Hydra
What prevent us from firing then?
There are a lot of wake up calls in our history like 47 war and loosing 2/3 kashmir, 65 war and loosing 1/3 airforce on day 1of war, 72 and loosing opportunity to gain anything significant or even forcing defeated enemy to release our POWs , Kargil blunder and loosing men just because some one didn’t do his job .
This last year wake up call is a routine Morning Alarm to IAF and India.
2020 ladakh wake up call
 
Absolutely true. Its beyond my understanding that if a noob can understand the advantage of making enemy jet defensive by launching solves(or at least 1) BVRAAM at Dmax simply by watching numerous engagements senerio on DCS, how can a professional pilot and a frofessional airforce worth of its salt could miss that.
Are our boys inferior to those DCS playing computer jockeys ? I mean just look at a YouTube by the name Growling sidewinder and the knowledge he has gained regarding WVR and BVR dogfights (mostly one on one) .
Don’t we have such culture among our boys? Are the flying jets just to fulfill their duty and earn salary ?

So its true that IAF hides its weakness till its *censored* is being whooped by PAF and then go for a routine ‘emergency buying spree’ to cope up with the humiliation and then after sit on their asses to repeat the cycle.

Not at all. There were simply no good options available. Astra was late along with RVV-SD. And Derby ER achieved IOC only in 2018. So it was all just bad timing. It's just that the IAF shouldn't skip over stopgap measures when available. Weapons should be of greater priority than weapons systems.

Look at our com systems now, another segment which is of higher priority than a weapons system. We have taken a massive lead over everyone else by switching over to the Rafael B-NET. Only 2 other air forces apart from Israel have it, and that's only Brazil and Colombia. All other air forces are a generation or two behind the IAF in this segment, even the USAF.
 
If we had responded swiftly for the PAF misadventures on 27th Feb, probably chinese could refrain from ladakh invasion.
All these years we were boasts about the chest measurements of a PM who turn down nation's wake up call for a military escalation, that too two times.
 
If we had responded swiftly for the PAF misadventures on 27th Feb, probably chinese could refrain from ladakh invasion.
All these years we were boasts about the chest measurements of a PM who turn down nation's wake up call for a military escalation, that too two times.

Modi does not understand the NEZ Technicalities of BVR Missiles or Software Defined Radios
Or about stupid ROEs

He can.only give money

If someone messed up it is IAF HQ

They planned and Trained for an all out War ie through Gagan Shakti exercise

But a 15 minute skirmish is a new thing

Anyway we.should only.learn from.mistakes

If the weaknesses had remained unknown , then we would have suffered much more in this present situation
 
He can.only give money

If someone messed up it is IAF HQ

They planned and Trained for an all out War ie through Gagan Shakti exercise

But a 15 minute skirmish is a new thing

Anyway we.should only.learn from.mistakes

If the weaknesses had remained unknown , then we would have suffered much more in this present situation
Gave money only for mere 36 rafale, sanctioned procurement of sfdr only after feb27.Hardened shelter for mkis were sanction few years back only. P75I still no where, artillery procurements are still dream. IA requirements for Biho is shelved. AWACS, 1 minute silence.Aerial refuelers, 2 minutes silence etc etc. These things can be rectified only by GOI.

So you want to convey that IAF has to conduct retaliation on paf without getting permission from ministry or are you telling that IAF denied retaliation orders from modi?

We still didn't learn anything, or else we would have start firing our bofors in ladakh.
 
Modi does not understand the NEZ Technicalities of BVR Missiles or Software Defined Radios
Or about stupid ROEs

He can.only give money

If someone messed up it is IAF HQ

They planned and Trained for an all out War ie through Gagan Shakti exercise

But a 15 minute skirmish is a new thing

Anyway we.should only.learn from.mistakes

If the weaknesses had remained unknown , then we would have suffered much more in this present situation
Someone needs to wake up these IAF guys to acquire PHALCON Awacs asap, it's the next big gap we have to fix.
 
Gave money only for mere 36 rafale, sanctioned procurement of sfdr only after feb27.Hardened shelter for mkis were sanction few years back only. P75I still no where, artillery procurements are still dream. IA requirements for Biho is shelved. AWACS, 1 minute silence.Aerial refuelers, 2 minutes silence etc etc. These things can be rectified only by GOI.

So you want to convey that IAF has to conduct retaliation on paf without getting permission from ministry or are you telling that IAF denied retaliation orders from modi?

We still didn't learn anything, or else we would have start firing our bofors in ladakh.

You are mixing up.two things

One is Modernisation and Force planning and Second is Feb 2019

Modernisation is done by Services HQ along with MOD Bureaucracy

It is The Bureaucrats who delay things

Secondly in this present Chinese aggression ,.it is the Lack of preparation and capabilities that we are seeing , all over again

What happened or did not happen after Feb 27 is another matter

It has been discussed before , no point in repeating everything
 
  • Like
Reactions: JustCurious
You are mixing up.two things

One is Modernisation and Force planning

This is done by Services HQ along with MOD Bureaucracy

It is The Bureaucrats who delay things

Secondly in this present Chinese aggression ,.it is the Lack of preparation that we are seeing

What happened or did not happen after Feb 27 is another matter

It has been discussed before , no point in repeating everything
So you agreed that we were not prepared, even after a feb 27. Ok, understood. We will never be prepared in that case.