Air Battle over Kashmir : MiG-21 Bison shoots down F-16

I don't exactly get why they keep claiming this, even veterans. Maybe they are saying it due to certain political compulsions, as a show of support to the Rafale, because I don't believe they do not know about the R-27. And then the fact that the MKI dodged AMRAAMs from 30Km away, putting the F-16s in the range of the shorter range R-77 as well. Nobody fires from Dmax anyway.

Pakistanis did.

And no, not 30 kms.
 
My post regarding the surprise was about the initial build up. IAF failed to correctly analyse the situation and build up. They reacted late when the entire strike was already in place.

It was always expected. There was no surprise. Scramble of ORPs took place as soon as they started coalescing into a package. It was correctly analysed and hence the fact that not a single PAF fighter crossed the LC. Had your contention as above been true, they would have actually crossed the LC.

Now imagine if we had started getting our fighters like Mig-29s/additional M2Ks and SU-30MKI airborne when we detected such large formations getting airborne in pak airspace. We should have suspected a game. But we delayed launch of additional fighters. I am very sure that if we had launched our own fighters when we noticed those formations, most likely PAF would not have even attempted what they did on 27th.

How much time does it take for a strike formation to come together after taking off from depth and then move into a particular direction in its own air space, analyse it, categorize the direction and magnitude of threat, evaluate the quantum and direction of own force needed to apply and at what time to defeat it, and in the meantime, clear your own airspace of your own civil air traffic in order to minimize your own casualties inadvertently?
 
It's not possible with the Phalcon's primary radar. SARH on the R-27 is X band. So only another X band radar can help guide it. An SARH missile works like a receiver to the fighter jet radar's transmitter. So the Bars's transmission that is reflected off the target is picked up by the R-27 which allows it to home in on the target. The Phalcon's L band will obviously not be recognised. So the only way this is possible is if the Phalcon also carries an X band radar. And this is only the hardware problem.

For the software bit, the R-27 would require integration with the Phalcon's radar, which is not possible considering it requires a lot of source code sharing between the Russians and Israelis.

However active radar missiles can be guided by AWACS using datalinks and the missile can then home in on the target using its own seeker. L band is not as accurate as a fighter jet radar, thereby increasing its chances of missing, but this is realistically possible. The same is also possible with an IR missile.

SARH missiles are generally built specifically for only fighter jet radars or SAM's FCR. This way the receiver is not cluttered with all sorts of unwanted signals.


Theoretically being the operative word ....

R-27s are deployed on Mig29s as of today.
 
.

Secondly, Pakistan wanted a war like situation?
I find this strange given they fully knew that in such a situation, they would have been hammered black and blue.
Given the current condition of pak (wasn't any different one year back), how were they thinking of going to a full blown war with India?

Please appreciate that nobody in this world will cheer you if you go to war against Pakistan. Diplomatic pressure will be immediate and will defeat our purpose also. Hence, war like and not war.
 
  • Like
Reactions: screambowl
The narrative is good to get new NG-BVRs.

Or outgunned because the aggressor was able to fire (obviously) first and scoot fast.


Neither ... just few PR seekers and majorly making a fool of the other side.
 
Pakistanis did.

And no, not 30 kms.
UASF fires from Dmax. They have a game in which they allow the initial boost phase of the missile to burnout before it can be picked up by passice MAWS and after that the dual pulse and radar homing come in together. UASF F-22s fire off by 130kms using AMRAAM-5D. The initial boost phase phase generates a temprature of over 1200*F which can be picked up by modern sensors from as far away as 50NM.
 
Please appreciate that nobody in this world will cheer you if you go to war against Pakistan. Diplomatic pressure will be immediate and will defeat our purpose also. Hence, war like and not war.

So does this mean that our response Next time will be as weak as last time
 
A.M. hari Kumar said nothing like that. Fanboys detached from realities come to twitter to vent their frustrations.

PAF acquired AIM-120, what can IAF do?
PN acquired SSB, what can IN do?
The quasi-military state acquired a nuclear device, what can India do?

We getting more nuclear devices won't nullify the effectiveness of pakistani nukes or more Arihants won't solve the SSB problem. similarly, PAF having AIM-120 did not take away our advantages of MICA or R-27. Say our mirages have had Meteor. Does that change the results? No. Did they get any kills ? No. AIM-120-C5 is on per with MICA or new Astra. US intentionally did not give better versions.

Crystal maze was integrated long ago with clearance from everyone involved. He mentioned procedural problems not technical. (Earlier Vishnu Som reported cloud cover which is the limitation of the weapon). A Phalcon was on the station so having more AWACS does not matter here. and PLAAF will do what again?

Secured datalink and software-defined radio.
Okay sir please read the article first before making any conclusions.. his first points was literally about PAF superior bvr missiles first shoot capability with better kinematic range.. they fired there first missile at close to 60km and last missile close to 40km. They had recording of our pilot's. Moreover my brother who is also a fighter pilot literally told me that they have better missiles than us . We could have bought the missiles that we bought in 2019 after balakot . There were a lot of time since 2008.I know quite well how Israeli weapons are integrated on mirgae (jugaad) without OEM because it was cheap. And after balakot IAF decided - it's best to consider OEM certification.. That's why one spice failed. Crystal maze are another story so just leave them out.
Really how can mica be on par with aim120. There weight difference is huge. You might mean there NEZ is similar but not overall range. R77 doesn't work reliably if the target is more than 35-40km away . Lastly Pakistani even have su30 pilots recording .. salute to the courage of that sikh guy who wasn't ready to give up . A lone su30 facing many f16 and it's missiles are not giving him firing solution.. I am really amazed how well Pakistan spend there defence budget compared to India. Lastly I haven't bring nuclear weapons or anything like that. My point is that they were getting better weapons than you and you were sleeping for years.
 
That will be actually good, you can tell us(again) how another 27th Feb is the best thing ever happened to India and IAF like you are doing about last one.

Sir there is No need to be so despondent
Okay sir please read the article first before making any conclusions.. his first points was literally about PAF superior bvr missiles first shoot capability with better kinematic range.. they fired there first missile at close to 60km and last missile close to 40km. They had recording of our pilot's. Moreover my brother who is also a fighter pilot literally told me that they have better missiles than us . We could have bought the missiles that we bought in 2019 after balakot . There were a lot of time since 2008.I know quite well how Israeli weapons are integrated on mirgae (jugaad) without OEM because it was cheap. And after balakot IAF decided - it's best to consider OEM certification.. That's why one spice failed. Crystal maze are another story so just leave them out.
Really how can mica be on par with aim120. There weight difference is huge. You might mean there NEZ is similar but not overall range. R77 doesn't work reliably if the target is more than 35-40km away . Lastly Pakistani even have su30 pilots recording .. salute to the courage of that sikh guy who wasn't ready to give up . A lone su30 facing many f16 and it's missiles are not giving him firing solution.. I am really amazed how well Pakistan spend there defence budget compared to India. Lastly I haven't bring nuclear weapons or anything like that. My point is that they were getting better weapons than you and you were sleeping for years.

What about the New Russian Missiles that we bought Recently
 
Okay sir please read the article first before making any conclusions.. his first points was literally about PAF superior bvr missiles first shoot capability with better kinematic range.. they fired there first missile at close to 60km and last missile close to 40km. They had recording of our pilot's. Moreover my brother who is also a fighter pilot literally told me that they have better missiles than us . We could have bought the missiles that we bought in 2019 after balakot . There were a lot of time since 2008.I know quite well how Israeli weapons are integrated on mirgae (jugaad) without OEM because it was cheap. And after balakot IAF decided - it's best to consider OEM certification.. That's why one spice failed. Crystal maze are another story so just leave them out.
Really how can mica be on par with aim120. There weight difference is huge. You might mean there NEZ is similar but not overall range. R77 doesn't work reliably if the target is more than 35-40km away . Lastly Pakistani even have su30 pilots recording .. salute to the courage of that sikh guy who wasn't ready to give up . A lone su30 facing many f16 and it's missiles are not giving him firing solution.. I am really amazed how well Pakistan spend there defence budget compared to India. Lastly I haven't bring nuclear weapons or anything like that. My point is that they were getting better weapons than you and you were sleeping for years.

But One thing you might have noticed is that after Feb 27 , they did not come close
To LOC again

And there were intense CAPs and Large scale exercises all along the border for several months

Even Pakistanis talked about it on Twitter

You should ask your brother about Post 27 Feb Revenge
 
  • Like
Reactions: screambowl
Sir there is No need to be so despondent


What about the New Russian Missiles that we bought Recently
There is no need to be ostrich I guess.

There is embarrassing similarity between IAF and PA. Both fail almost humiliatingly whenever trusted to deliver, botch up most missions and if not for individual acts of small small victories they would be complete embarrassment (PA already achieved that feat btw, IAF is toiling hard to catch-up).

Both have almost similar kind of leadership, more interested in blame games, domestic politics than defence and now both have their own full fledged production houses that feed propaganda instead of actual footage (a norm worldwide). Maybe that's the reason both have almost similar set of fanboys that gulp down everything thrown at them.

Every nation release HD Footage of enemy assets blowing up, here 1.25 billion people are told if we show you, enemy will know our 'capabilities' and that line is than used by most reputed, educated, informed ones to fool masses. They seriously think people are so stupid that they will believe anything they say because it's about 'patriotism'?.
 
Sir there is No need to be so despondent


What about the New Russian Missiles that we bought Recently
It will not make a difference we bought r27 and r77sd. . The outcome will most likely be the same if we are outnumbered again. R27 have good range but it's sensor aren't good.. on the other hand r77sd will match them but don't think PAF hasn't upgraded anything .. they got newer Chinese missiles on there jf17 , if they had operational data link like they have with link16 , even jf17 block 3 will give IAF hard time. This time they were dud because they were older variant but that's will not be the cases with jf17 block 3 with aesa radar.. they are also upgrading f16 with the help of Turkey and other nations.
 
There is no need to be ostrich I guess.

There is embarrassing similarity between IAF and PA. Both fail almost humiliatingly whenever trusted to deliver, botch up most missions and if not for individual acts of small small victories they would be complete embarrassment (PA already achieved that feat btw, IAF is toiling hard to catch-up).

Both have almost similar kind of leadership, more interested in blame games, domestic politics than defence and now both have their own full fledged production houses that feed propaganda instead of actual footage (a norm worldwide). Maybe that's the reason both have almost similar set of fanboys that gulp down everything thrown at them.

Every nation release HD Footage of enemy assets blowing up, here 1.25 billion people are told if we show you, enemy will know our 'capabilities' and that line is than used by most reputed, educated, informed ones to fool masses. They seriously think people are so stupid that they will believe anything they say because it's about 'patriotism'?.

Hello. We could evict.them.from Kargil
ONLY because of IAF

Otherwise it was impossible

How do you propose to record the Bombs striking the Target

IAF has said they.will.use Crystal Maze next time

And your "Favourite " PAF wasted 6 Amraams , 11 H 4 and also lost an F 16 to an MIG 21

IAF has accepted its mistakes and shortcomings but the ONLY WAY these shortcomings are known is through Real.War , not Red Flag exercises

Who was sleeping from 2004 till 2014

Who refused to.respond after 26 / 11

If IAF was so useless then PAF and PLAAF would have Jointly attacked us after Feb 27
 
It will not make a difference we bought r27 and r77sd. . The outcome will most likely be the same if we are outnumbered again. R27 have good range but it's sensor aren't good.. on the other hand r77sd will match them but don't think PAF hasn't upgraded anything .. they got newer Chinese missiles on there jf17 , if they had operational data link like they have with link16 , even jf17 block 3 will give IAF hard time. This time they were dud because they were older variant but that's will not be the cases with jf17 block 3 with aesa radar.. they are also upgrading f16 with the help of Turkey and other nations.

All this PAF upgrades are known to me
Having read.it in PDF

The thing is that War Is NOT A cricket match

First You BAT , then I will BAT :ROFLMAO:

As I said.earlier they.can.send a
30 plane Package Everyday.

What matters is.how.you Respond

Response means Retaliation

Scrambling your fighters is Not a response ,it.is a.reaction

War is about.seizing the Initiative
Hit First ,.Hit Hard
 
every nation release HD Footage of enemy assets blowing up, here 1.25 billion people are told if we show you, enemy will know our 'capabilities' and that line is than used by most reputed, educated, informed ones to fool masses. They seriously think people are so stupid that they will believe anything they say because it's about 'patriotism'?.
Sir you are the only person who speaks with some common sense.. even turkey released better proof than IAF
 
What about JSTAR


NEWSBREAK: Turbulence Ends, India Set To Acquire U.S. ISTAR Jet, 4 More With Indian Sensors

DRDO to develop its own ISTAR aircraft for IAF – Indian Defence Research Wing

That's pretty much a done deal. So I don't know how it will play a part after Trump's reelection.

IAF is interested in 100 Predator Cs. This may come up during the next term.
Actually AI can do it quite effectively. Particularly in chaotic environment, AI and ML is far more effective than any human being. ML is extensively used to extract meaningful information from extremely noisy data.

Great, then I hope this is eventually implemented.
 
All this PAF upgrades are known to me
Having read.it in PDF

The thing is that War Is NOT A cricket match

First You BAT , then I will BAT :ROFLMAO:

As I said.earlier they.can.send a
30 plane Package Everyday.

What matters is.how.you Respond

Response means Retaliation

Scrambling your fighters is Not a response ,it.is a.reaction

War is about.seizing the Initiative
Hit First ,.Hit Hard
I will be honest with you, IAF has lost the edge that they had during Kargil and if Pakistan had aim120 than that war would have been whole another story. IAF advantage only comes when there is full fledge war , which is not going to happen because Pakistan have nuclear weapons. Bottom line .. so until someone come up with a good laser to shoot down missiles in seconds at more than 100km, there is nothing going to happen.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Paro
Sir you are the only person who speaks with some common sense.. even turkey released better proof than IAF

Do you really think Every time a bomb is released , it hits the Target

Even US which bombs countries without
Air defences or Fighter planes must be missing their targets

Russia is still struggling in Syria after so many years

All Stand off weapons do have CEP

Only Dumb bombs can be accurately dropped just over the target
 
Pakistanis did.

And no, not 30 kms.

Then that's more wrong info peddled by veterans.

Theoretically being the operative word ....

R-27s are deployed on Mig29s as of today.

On both actually.

jx1tpxgr8yi31.jpg

My point is that they were getting better weapons than you and you were sleeping for years.

Read post 1487.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Hellfire