This was the first prototype at #Chennai in 2018. pic.twitter.com/KKsx7RZkF6
— Ninjamonkey 🇮🇳 (@Aryan_warlord) February 5, 2020
This was the first prototype at #Chennai in 2018. pic.twitter.com/KKsx7RZkF6
— Ninjamonkey 🇮🇳 (@Aryan_warlord) February 5, 2020
OFB's SHARANG Artillery Gun
— Directorate of Ordnance (@DoO_India) February 4, 2020
https://t.co/VzbecRh7Z6
Better photo :
View attachment 13879
Excalbur is the GPS guided round. This is a whole different thing. If made this will allow us to shoot projectiles some 150 kms away.Will it be less expensive than Excalibur
That is the real question
It will probably reach Islamabad / Pindi from say Poonch....lolExcalbur is the GPS guided round. This is a whole different thing. If made this will allow us to shoot projectiles some 150 kms away.
Kalyani 155mm/39 Cal ULH is set to undergo user trials very soon. The company expects trials to finish by 2021. pic.twitter.com/ZizDZD2J8n
— Delhi Defence Review (@delhidefence) February 5, 2020
Excalbur is the GPS guided round. This is a whole different thing. If made this will allow us to shoot projectiles some 150 kms away.
Any new tech is expensive. But then similar tech if imported will cost much higher. There are other problems too. The problem with putting an air-breathing engine in a artillery round it that it will greatly reduce internal volume. Meaning the explosive and the electronics/guidance package on the round will have less space to work with. Any artillery fired at a range greater than about 40 km will need active guidance(GPS based, laser guided or something similar) to achieve less than 2m CEP. If you are shooting at 150 km guidance will have to be an integral part of the design. How we go about solve these problems will be interesting to watch."IF" is the point of focus here. Also, the cost of each round will be substantially higher than normal artillery rounds. That will put us in the proverbial brahmos situation. Sure, it will be a massive boost to our arsenal but the cost will be prohibitive and would only be used to target high value targets. So, say during an artillary duel, it won't be used. Only cheaper rounds that can be expanded at whim will be used.
On the other hand, it will be cheaper than an actual missile and will give us an cost effective alternate to any tactical level short range missile. It will be difficult to intercept as well.
I don't know how much miniaturisation we can achieve with nukes. I believe a 155mm based nuke round can be done. However with a ramjet engine taking up space we will need an even smaller nuke. If we can make one, and its a big if, I highly doubt those will have the power to take out a city. It might take out an airbase though.Now, imagine if we put a miniaturized nuke warhead in that round. Forget the tactical nuke missiles that pak keeps harping about, this will become THE most frightening thing in our arsenal that will give pak sleepless nights. Now, imagine the nuclear blackmail that India can enact on pakistan. One more mumbai/pulwama and islamabad will go pufffff in seconds. No ballistic missile shield can save them.
"IF" is the point of focus here. Also, the cost of each round will be substantially higher than normal artillery rounds. That will put us in the proverbial brahmos situation. Sure, it will be a massive boost to our arsenal but the cost will be prohibitive and would only be used to target high value targets. So, say during an artillary duel, it won't be used. Only cheaper rounds that can be expanded at whim will be used.
On the other hand, it will be cheaper than an actual missile and will give us an cost effective alternate to any tactical level short range missile. It will be difficult to intercept as well.
Now, imagine if we put a miniaturized nuke warhead in that round. Forget the tactical nuke missiles that pak keeps harping about, this will become THE most frightening thing in our arsenal that will give pak sleepless nights. Now, imagine the nuclear blackmail that India can enact on pakistan. One more mumbai/pulwama and islamabad will go pufffff in seconds. No ballistic missile shield can save them.
They have not done cost analysis. They will use aluminum based fuel instead of boron based for the reason of cost and availability. IIT kanpur and RCI will provide guidance system. Definitely it will be costlier to basic shell but may be less than that of Excalibur. Details are as followWill it be less expensive than Excalibur
That is the real question
A project associate from @iitmadras takes us through various details related to the *ramjet* powered artillery shell project being undertaken by his institution. Range capability is around double that of ERFB BB rounds.https://t.co/EDeJREo0zl
— Saurav Jha (@SJha1618) February 6, 2020
They have not done cost analysis. They will use aluminum based fuel instead of boron based for the reason of cost and availability. IIT kanpur and RCI will provide guidance system. Definitely it will be costlier to basic shell but may be less than that of Excalibur. Details are as followWill it be less expensive than Excalibur
That is the real question
A project associate from @iitmadras takes us through various details related to the *ramjet* powered artillery shell project being undertaken by his institution. Range capability is around double that of ERFB BB rounds.https://t.co/EDeJREo0zl
— Saurav Jha (@SJha1618) February 6, 2020
Now, imagine if we put a miniaturized nuke warhead in that round. Forget the tactical nuke missiles that pak keeps harping about, this will become THE most frightening thing in our arsenal that will give pak sleepless nights. Now, imagine the nuclear blackmail that India can enact on pakistan. One more mumbai/pulwama and islamabad will go pufffff in seconds. No ballistic missile shield can save them.
tactical nukes of that size disrupt the command and control structure for Nuke engagement.
Nukes are last ditch effort to destroy something - it creates a bad precedent.
we should let Pak continue to blackmail us with miniature nukes and use that as an excuse to build up conventional capabilities.
The monies required to research mini nukes/ their storage/ handling/ prevention of these nukes falling into wrong hands is a mess.